Summary
The customer notices it in summer: the heating has been off since April, the hot water comes on at 6 am, and the landing radiator is warm by seven. Or the thermostat is turned down, the boiler is heating the cylinder, and the whole house is warm anyway. It wastes gas, it overheats the house, and on a Y-plan it is often the first sign that the mid-position valve is on its way out and the "no hot water" call is next. On a combi the pattern is different — radiators warm after a long shower, nothing to do with the heating programme — and the cause is inside the boiler.
The diagnosis is a matter of knowing the system type and feeling three pipes. This guide gives the causes by system type, the five-minute tests, the decision tree, the wiring faults that mimic a passing valve, the repair options with times and prices, and when the honest answer is a check valve rather than a new valve. For the valves themselves see zone valves and wiring; for the controls that should be stopping the flow see heating controls.
Key Facts
- S-plan (two or more 2-port valves) — one valve on the heating flow, one on the cylinder primary flow; each opens on demand and its end switch fires the boiler and pump. Radiators warm during hot water only = the heating 2-port is passing (seal or paddle worn, or the valve not fully closing because the motor or return spring has failed)
- Y-plan (one 3-port mid-position valve) — the valve directs flow to the cylinder (port A, hot water only), to the radiators (port B, heating only), or both (mid position). Radiators warm during hot water only = the valve is not returning fully to the A position: worn seal, weak return spring, a sticking spindle, or a failed head leaving it mid-way. Y-plan valves fail this way more than any other
- W-plan and older priority systems — a 3-port diverter (either/or, no mid position); passing shows as both circuits warm at once
- Gravity circulation — on older systems where the cylinder primary was gravity (no pump, no valve) and the heating pumped, or where a conversion left no check valve, hot water rising from the boiler circulates slowly through the radiators on its own. Classic sign: upstairs radiators warm, downstairs cold, no pump running. Fix: a check valve (non-return) on the heating flow, or a 2-port valve with proper controls
- Combi — the diverter valve inside the boiler sends the primary water to the plate heat exchanger for hot water or to the radiators for heating. A diverter that is passing, or a diaphragm that has failed, lets some flow reach the radiators during hot water draw-off; radiators warm after a shower in summer. The reverse fault, no hot water or lukewarm hot water, is the same valve
- Heating "off" that is not off — a programmer in "advance" or "boost", a room thermostat with a stuck contact or anticipator, a frost thermostat calling, a wiring fault that links the heating and hot water calls (common after a programmer swap on a Y-plan where terminal 1 "HW off" is mis-wired), or a smart thermostat scheduled to a setpoint the customer did not notice
- Bypass that is meant to be there — an automatic bypass valve (required by Approved Document L for most boilers unless the manufacturer says otherwise) lets flow circulate when zone valves close; a bypass radiator with no TRV and no valve on a gravity-era system, usually the bathroom towel rail, is designed to be warm whenever the boiler runs. Do not condemn a towel rail that is doing its job
- The pipe-feel test — with hot water on and heating off, feel the heating flow pipe 300 mm after the heating valve (S-plan) or on port B of the mid-position valve (Y-plan): hot = valve passing. Then feel the boiler flow and the cylinder flow to confirm the boiler is running for hot water, not heating
- The manual-lever test — on a 2-port with a manual lever, the lever should be free to move when the valve is de-energised and closed; a lever that is stuck in the open position or the valve that stays warm with the lever released indicates a stuck paddle or a failed spring
- Head-off test — remove the head (two screws or a clip on most types) with the power isolated; the spindle below should be at the closed position and should turn freely by hand. A spindle that will not return or feels gritty is a body fault; a head that does not drive it is a head fault
- Head replacement — 30–45 minutes, £40–£90 for a 2-port head, £60–£120 for a mid-position head; no drain-down. Check the replacement head suits the body (same manufacturer and type; some heads are interchangeable across brands and some are not)
- Body replacement — 1–2 hours with a drain-down or pipe freeze; 22 mm 2-port body £40–£80, 22 mm mid-position body £60–£130; valve with head £80–£200; inhibitor top-up afterwards (BS 7593:2019)
- Check valve — a 22 mm swing or spring check valve on the heating flow for gravity circulation: £15–£40, 45–60 minutes with a drain-down, often the whole fix on an old system
- Combi diverter — diverter valve or diaphragm kit £30–£150, 1–2 hours by a Gas Safe engineer (case off); fitted £150–£350
- Part P and Gas Safe — replacing a valve head or body on the existing wiring is not notifiable electrical work; combi internals are gas-appliance work for a Gas Safe registered engineer
- Approved Document L (2021) — any system without independent time and temperature control of heating and hot water is below the current standard; where you find a gravity primary with no valve, the upgrade (cylinder stat, 2-port valve, interlock) is the compliant fix when the boiler is replaced and good advice before
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| System | Symptom | Most likely cause | Confirming test | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S-plan | Radiators warm during hot water only | Heating 2-port valve passing | Pipe after valve hot with heating off | Replace head or body |
| S-plan | Radiators warm with everything off and boiler not running | Gravity circulation from a hot cylinder primary back through the heating | Boiler cold; pipes warm; no pump | Check valve; check pipework layout |
| Y-plan | Radiators warm during hot water only | Mid-position valve not returning to A | Port B pipe hot; head-off spindle test | Replace head (first) or body |
| Y-plan | Heating runs when programmer says HW only | Wiring: terminal 1 (HW off) missing or wrong at programmer; valve grey/orange swapped | Check wiring centre against diagram | Correct wiring |
| Any with cylinder | Upstairs radiators warm, downstairs cold, pump off | Gravity (thermosiphon) circulation | Pump not running; warmth rises slowly | Check valve on heating flow |
| Any | Radiators warm, boiler firing, programmer shows heating off | Room stat, frost stat, or programmer relay stuck closed | 230 V on the heating call wire with controls off | Replace the faulty control |
| Combi | Radiators warm after hot tap or shower, summer | Diverter valve passing or diaphragm failed | Radiators warm only after DHW use; boiler on HW only | Gas Safe engineer replaces diverter or diaphragm |
| Combi | Radiators warm and heating light on with stat off | Room stat or link wire; boiler in frost mode; integral clock | Check stat terminals and boiler display | Correct control or wiring |
| Any | One towel rail or radiator warm when heating off | Bypass radiator (no valve) or open bypass loop by design | Check for valves on that radiator | Explain; fit TRV only if a bypass remains |
| Any | All radiators warm, heating off, after a new programmer | Programmer wired as single channel or links wrong | Compare with programmer backplate diagram | Rewire programmer |
Detailed Guidance
Decision tree
Radiators warm when heating is off
│
├── System type?
│ ├── COMBI → does it happen only after hot water use?
│ │ ├── Yes → diverter valve passing / diaphragm → Gas Safe engineer
│ │ └── No → heating is being called: room stat, link wire,
│ │ frost mode, integral clock → check controls
│ └── CYLINDER system (S-plan / Y-plan / gravity) → continue
│
├── Is the boiler running when it happens?
│ ├── No (boiler cold, pump off, radiators slowly warming upstairs)
│ │ → GRAVITY CIRCULATION from the hot cylinder primary
│ │ → check valve on heating flow; check for missing valve
│ └── Yes → continue
│
├── Is the boiler running for HOT WATER (cylinder stat calling, HW valve open)?
│ ├── Yes → feel heating flow after heating valve (S-plan) / port B (Y-plan)
│ │ ├── Hot → VALVE PASSING
│ │ │ → head-off: spindle at closed position and free?
│ │ │ ├── Spindle open/stuck/gritty → BODY (or valve) fault
│ │ │ └── Spindle fine, head not driving → HEAD fault
│ │ └── Cold → radiators warm from elsewhere: second valve, bypass,
│ │ or wiring calling heating as well → check wiring
│ └── No, boiler running for HEATING with programmer/stat "off"
│ → 230 V on heating call wire? trace: programmer relay, room stat,
│ frost stat, smart stat schedule, wiring centre links
│
└── Only one radiator / towel rail warm?
→ bypass radiator by design, or TRV/lockshield passing on a radiator
fed from a bypass loop → explain or fit valves with a bypass retained
S-plan: the passing 2-port
A 2-port zone valve is a motor that drives a paddle against a seal; when the motor is de-energised a spring returns the paddle to closed. Three things let it pass: the rubber seal has worn or taken debris; the spring has weakened so the paddle does not seat; the motor has partially failed so it stays somewhere between. The head-off test separates them. Isolate the controls at the fused spur, remove the head, and look at the spindle: it should be at the closed stop and should turn with a firm finger. If it turns freely to closed and the pipe still warms with the valve de-energised, the seal is passing and the body is replaced. If the spindle is stiff or stuck open, the body is replaced. If the spindle is fine and the head will not drive it or does not release, the head is replaced. Heads are the common fix and take 30–45 minutes without touching the water; bodies need a drain-down of the circuit (or a pipe freeze either side) and 1–2 hours. Top up inhibitor afterwards to BS 7593:2019 and check the system pressure or F&E cistern level.
Y-plan: the mid-position valve that will not go home
The mid-position valve has one inlet and two outlets (A to cylinder, B to heating) and three positions. In the hot-water-only position the motor is de-energised and the spring returns the ball or paddle to shut off port B. When the spring weakens, the spindle wears, or the seal around port B hardens, flow leaks through to the radiators during hot water. This is the most common reason for warm radiators in summer on a Y-plan house, and the valve is often 15–25 years old. The head is replaced first (same manufacturer, correct type), because most of the failures are the head's return mechanism and the microswitches; if the body's spindle is sloppy or the leak persists, the body follows. A Y-plan body is a 3-port fitting with 22 mm compression connections; the replacement must be the same pattern or the pipe positions change.
Wiring mimics the fault on Y-plan more than on S-plan. The programmer's terminal 1 (hot water off) feeds the valve's grey wire; terminal 3 (hot water on) feeds the cylinder stat; terminal 4 (heating on) feeds the room stat and then the white wire; the orange is the switched live back to the boiler. A programmer swap that leaves terminal 1 unconnected, or a grey and white swapped at the wiring centre, puts the valve in mid-position whenever hot water is called, and the radiators warm. Check the wiring against the standard Y-plan diagram before condemning the valve. See zone valves and wiring and boiler programmer not working.
Gravity circulation
Hot water rises. On a system where the boiler sits below the radiators and the heating flow leaves the boiler and climbs — most houses — hot water in the boiler during a cylinder heat-up will circulate through the heating circuit by convection alone unless a closed valve or a check valve stops it. On a correctly piped S-plan or Y-plan the closed valve does that. On an old system where the cylinder was heated by gravity and the heating pumped, there is often no valve on the heating flow at all, only the pump, and a stationary pump does not stop convection. The symptom is slow: upstairs radiators warm to the touch an hour into a hot water cycle, the boiler barely working. The fix is a check valve on the heating flow (a spring type, oriented correctly, after the pump) or, better, bringing the system up to Approved Document L with a cylinder stat, a 2-port valve on the cylinder primary, a 2-port on the heating and a wiring centre with interlock. The second is the right answer when the boiler is being replaced and good advice before, because it also stops the cylinder heating to boiler temperature — see hot water too hot cylinder thermostat.
Combi diverter valves
Inside a combi, the diverter valve (motorised on most modern boilers, hydraulic diaphragm on many older ones) switches the primary water between the heating circuit and the plate heat exchanger when a hot tap opens. When it passes — worn seal, failed diaphragm, a motor that does not travel fully — some primary flow reaches the radiators during hot water draw, and after a long shower on a summer morning the radiators are warm. The same valve failing the other way gives lukewarm hot water while the radiators heat. Diagnosis is by exclusion: heating controls genuinely off, boiler showing hot water mode, radiators warm only after draw-off. The repair is a diverter valve or a diaphragm kit, behind the case, by a Gas Safe registered engineer, 1–2 hours, £150–£350 fitted. See no hot water but heating works for the companion fault and boiler repair pricing guide for the figures.
Controls that are not off
Before a valve is condemned, prove the heating is not being called. With the programmer on hot water only and the room stat at minimum, there should be no 230 V on the heating call wire at the wiring centre (the white on a Y-plan; the live to the heating 2-port on an S-plan). If there is, trace it: a programmer whose heating relay has welded, a room thermostat with stuck contacts, a frost thermostat in a cold loft set too high and wired to call heating, a smart thermostat with a hidden schedule or a "pre-heat" learning function, a boiler in frost-protection mode (which runs the pump and may fire the boiler at low temperature when the boiler's internal sensor drops below about 5 °C), or a link wire left in a wiring centre from a previous repair. See thermostat not working.
Bypass radiators and the honest conversation
Older systems were piped with one radiator — usually the bathroom towel rail — without valves, so the pump always had somewhere to push water when every other radiator's TRV closed. Approved Document L now expects an automatic bypass valve instead, and modern boilers have one or require one. A towel rail that is warm whenever the boiler runs for hot water is doing its job. If the customer wants it cold in summer, fit a TRV and lockshield to it and an automatic bypass valve across the flow and return near the boiler (if the boiler does not have one internally), and set the bypass per the boiler's instructions. Do not simply valve off the only bypass — the pump will run against a closed system, the boiler will overheat and short-cycle, and the heat exchanger will complain. See boiler short cycling diagnosis.
Charging the job
| Job | Time | Parts | Typical charge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diagnose (pipe-feel, head-off, wiring check) | 30–45 min | — | £60–£110 |
| Replace 2-port valve head | 30–45 min | £40–£90 | £110–£190 |
| Replace mid-position valve head | 30–45 min | £60–£120 | £130–£220 |
| Replace 2-port valve body (drain or freeze), inhibitor | 1–2 h | £50–£110 | £180–£320 |
| Replace mid-position valve body, inhibitor | 1.5–2.5 h | £80–£160 | £220–£380 |
| Fit check valve for gravity circulation | 45–60 min + drain | £15–£40 | £120–£200 |
| Correct programmer or wiring centre fault | 30–60 min | £0–£20 | £70–£130 |
| Combi diverter valve or diaphragm (Gas Safe) | 1–2 h | £30–£150 | £150–£350 |
| Upgrade gravity system to S-plan controls (Part L) | Half to full day | £200–£400 | £450–£850 |
See plumber hourly rate guide and gas engineer hourly rate guide for the rates behind the figures.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are my radiators hot when the heating is off?
Hot water meant for the cylinder is leaking into the heating circuit. On a system with a hot water cylinder the usual cause is a motorised valve that is not closing fully — a two-port on an S-plan or the mid-position valve on a Y-plan — or, on an older system, gravity circulation with nothing to stop it. On a combi it is the internal diverter valve passing, so radiators warm after a shower. Occasionally the heating is actually being called by a faulty thermostat, programmer or wiring.
Why do my radiators come on when the hot water is on?
Because the valve that should send all the boiler's output to the cylinder is passing some to the radiators. Feel the heating pipe just after the valve while the hot water is heating and the heating is off: if it is hot, the valve is passing. Replace the valve head first (30–45 minutes, no drain-down); if the fault persists, replace the valve body.
Is it dangerous if radiators heat up when the heating is off?
No, but it wastes gas, overheats the house in summer and is usually an early warning that the valve will fail completely, at which point you lose heating or hot water. Fix it in summer when it is a convenient job rather than in the first cold week when the valve finally sticks.
Why does my combi make the radiators warm when I run the hot tap?
The diverter valve inside the boiler, which switches flow between the heating circuit and the hot water heat exchanger, is passing — a worn seal or a failed diaphragm. It is repaired by a Gas Safe registered engineer replacing the valve or the diaphragm kit; the cost is typically £150–£350. The same fault often also gives lukewarm hot water.
My towel rail is always warm even in summer — is that a fault?
Probably not. On many systems the bathroom towel rail is piped without valves as a bypass so the pump always has a route when other radiators shut off. If you want it cold in summer, it needs valves fitted and an automatic bypass valve installed near the boiler to take over the bypass role; simply valving it off would damage the boiler.
Regulations & Standards
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings (2021 edition) — heating and hot water controls; independent time and temperature control; boiler interlock; bypass requirements
Domestic Building Services Compliance Guide (2021 edition) — control specifications for wet central heating; zoning and interlock
BS 7593:2019 — code of practice for the preparation, commissioning and maintenance of domestic central heating and cooling water systems; inhibitor after any drain-down
BS 7671:2018+A4:2026 — Requirements for Electrical Installations; isolation and working on control wiring
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document P (2013 edition) — like-for-like replacement of controls not notifiable
Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998 (SI 1998/2451) — work inside a combi boiler by Gas Safe registered engineers
Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 (SI 1989/635) — safe isolation of heating controls
BS EN IEC 60730-2-8:2025 — automatic electrical controls; particular requirements for electrically operated water valves (zone and mid-position valve heads)
Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999 — check valves and backflow devices where fitted on open-vented systems
Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings (2021) — gov.uk; controls and interlock
Domestic Building Services Compliance Guide — gov.uk; zoning, bypass and control specifications
Gas Safe Register — Who can carry out gas work — combi internals
BS 7593:2019 — BSI Knowledge — water treatment after system work
HHIC — Heating and Hotwater Industry Council technical guidance — system controls and commissioning
CIPHE — Chartered Institute of Plumbing and Heating Engineering — wet system design guidance
zone valves and wiring — S-plan and Y-plan valves and their wiring
heating controls — the controls that should be stopping the flow
boiler programmer not working — when the programmer is calling heating it should not
thermostat not working — stuck thermostats and frost stats
no hot water but heating works — the same valves failing the other way
hot water too hot cylinder thermostat — the gravity-era system's other symptom
boiler short cycling diagnosis — what happens when the bypass is removed
combi vs system vs conventional — why the fault differs by system type
boiler repair pricing guide — pricing the combi repair