Summary

Scalding water from the hot tap is a safety call, not a comfort call. Water at 60 °C causes a full-thickness burn in about five seconds; at 70 °C in under a second. Children, older people and anyone with reduced sensation are the casualties, and the Building Regulations and HSE guidance treat the hot water temperature as a safety control, not a preference. The usual story is a cylinder thermostat that has either been turned up "to get more hot water" or has failed with its contacts stuck closed, so the boiler heats the cylinder every time the hot water programme runs until the boiler's own thermostat stops it — at 75–82 °C. On an open-vented system the cylinder expands into the cistern, the vent pipe steams, and the airing cupboard is tropical; on an unvented cylinder the stat's overheat cut-out trips, and if that fails the T&P relief valve opens and the tundish runs.

The fix is almost always a £15–£40 thermostat and an hour. The job is diagnosing which thermostat, proving it, and then checking the two things the symptom has exposed: whether the system has the controls it should have, and whether the outlets need thermostatic mixing valves. This guide gives the temperatures that matter, the tests by cylinder type, the decision tree, the wiring of a cylinder thermostat on S-plan and Y-plan systems, the immersion faults, the unvented safety devices, and the repair costs. For the legionella side see legionella management; for the valves that make taps safe see thermostatic mixing valves.

Key Facts

Quick Reference Table

Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.

Try squote free →
Symptom Cylinder type Most likely cause Confirming test Fix
Taps scalding, airing cupboard very hot, vent steaming or cistern warm Open-vented, boiler heated Cylinder stat set too high or contacts welded; stat strapped over insulation Stat setting; continuity test; cylinder temperature vs setpoint Reset or replace stat; re-fix to bare copper
Taps scalding, radiators also warm during HW Open-vented, Y-plan Stat satisfied contact not switching; valve mid-position Y-plan wiring and stat test Replace stat; check valve
Taps scalding, no stat or valve on cylinder Gravity primary System follows boiler temperature by design Visual: no stat, no valve on primary Retrofit stat + 2-port + interlock (Part L)
Taps scalding only when immersion used Any Immersion stat failed closed or set to max Immersion stat setting; test Replace immersion stat (or element on unvented)
Taps scalding in summer, boiler off Solar thermal No or failed blending valve at cylinder Cylinder at 80 °C+; outlet unblended Fit or replace TMV/blending valve
Tundish discharging hot water Unvented Overheat: control stat failed, overheat stat tripped, T&P opened Reset overheat stat; test control stat Replace control stat; check expansion vessel (if discharge is cold, it is expansion, not overheat)
Hot water too hot, then none at all Any Overheat cut-out tripped after a stat failure Reset button on immersion/overheat stat Replace the failed control stat before resetting
Boiler cycling constantly on HW, cylinder scalding Any Stat calling permanently; cylinder at boiler temp Stat continuity Replace stat
Water hotter upstairs than downstairs Any No fault at the cylinder; downstairs dead leg cooling Measure at both Normal; consider secondary return or TMVs

Detailed Guidance

Decision tree

Hot water too hot at the taps
│
├── Measure at the nearest hot tap after 1 minute: ___ °C
│   ├── 55–65 °C → within the normal storage range; scald risk at outlets
│   │              → recommend TMVs at bath/basins; set stat to 60 °C
│   └── > 65 °C → something is over-heating the cylinder → continue
│
├── What heats the cylinder?
│   ├── Boiler (S-plan / Y-plan / gravity)
│   │     ├── Is there a cylinder thermostat?
│   │     │     ├── No  → GRAVITY PRIMARY: cylinder follows boiler
│   │     │     │         → retrofit stat + 2-port + interlock
│   │     │     └── Yes → setting?
│   │     │           ├── > 65 °C → set to 60 °C, re-test
│   │     │           └── ≤ 65 °C → stat fixed to bare copper, strap tight?
│   │     │                 ├── No  → re-fix on copper, re-test
│   │     │                 └── Yes → continuity test: does it open above
│   │     │                           setpoint?
│   │     │                       ├── No  → STAT FAILED → replace
│   │     │                       └── Yes → stat fine: valve passing or
│   │     │                                 wiring (Y-plan terminal 1 / 2)
│   │     │                                 → see radiators-hot guide
│   ├── Immersion
│   │     → immersion stat set 60 °C? → continuity test → replace stat
│   │       (unvented: element with integral cut-out; check cut-out reset)
│   ├── Solar thermal / thermal store
│   │     → blending valve present and working? → fit or replace TMV
│   └── Heat pump
│         → pasteurisation immersion stat / controller setting → correct
│
└── Unvented cylinder: tundish discharging?
      ├── Hot water discharge → OVERHEAT: control stat failed; overheat
      │     stat or T&P operated → replace control stat; test safety
      │     devices; G3 installer
      └── Cold/warm intermittent discharge → EXPANSION: vessel charge or
            diaphragm → not a temperature fault

The cylinder thermostat: position, setting, wiring

The strap-on stat reads the copper through its back plate; it has to be on bare copper, pressed firmly by the strap, with the foam jacket cut away behind it and replaced over it. A stat strapped outside a foam jacket, or over a crease in a factory-foamed cylinder's skin, reads 10–20 °C low and lets the cylinder run away. It sits roughly one-third of the way up the cylinder (most manufacturers specify 300–400 mm from the base on a 900–1,200 mm cylinder) so that it registers the bulk of the stored water, not the hot layer at the top.

On an S-plan the stat simply switches the programmer's hot water live to the hot water 2-port valve motor; valve open, end switch fires boiler and pump. On a Y-plan the stat has a common (fed from programmer terminal 3, hot water on), a demand terminal that feeds the boiler and pump directly for hot water, and a satisfied terminal that feeds the mid-position valve's grey wire to drive it over to heating only. A Y-plan stat wired with the demand and satisfied terminals swapped heats the cylinder continuously and puts the valve in the wrong position: the symptom is too-hot water plus radiators warm during hot water. See zone valves and wiring and radiators hot when heating off.

To test: isolate at the fused spur and verify dead. Disconnect the stat's wires and measure continuity between common and demand with the cylinder hot (above the setpoint): it should be open. Turn the dial up past the cylinder's temperature: it should click and close. Turn it back: it should open. A stat that does neither, or that is closed at every setting, is replaced. Set the new one at 60 °C and mark the dial.

Gravity systems without a stat

A pre-1980s system where the cylinder primary is heated by gravity circulation has no valve, often no stat, and the cylinder heats to whatever the boiler's thermostat is set to — 70–80 °C — every time the boiler runs for heating. The owner turns the boiler stat down to 60 °C to cope and then has cold radiators. The correct fix is the Approved Document L controls package: a cylinder thermostat, a 2-port motorised valve on the primary flow to the cylinder, a wiring centre, and the valve's end switch interlocking the boiler, so the boiler stops when both the cylinder and the room are satisfied. On a gravity primary the valve must be a type suitable for gravity flow (full-bore, mounted to allow convection when open) or the primary converted to pumped. It is half a day and £350–£650, it saves gas, and it is required when the boiler is replaced. See heating controls.

Immersion heaters

The immersion's rod thermostat sits in a pocket inside the element and is adjustable with a screwdriver, 50–80 °C with a 60 °C mark. Failed closed, it heats the cylinder until the water boils on a vented cylinder — banging, steam from the vent into the cistern, the cistern warm — or until the thermal cut-out opens on a modern element. Replacement thermostats are a standard length (commonly 11 inches / 280 mm and 18 inches / 457 mm) and cost £10–£30; swap it with the power isolated and verified dead at the 20 A double-pole switch, test the element's insulation resistance while you are there, and set it to 60 °C. On an unvented cylinder the immersion must be a type with an integral thermal cut-out (BS EN 60335-2-73), and the cut-out is a one-shot or resettable device that opened because the control stat failed: replace the stat or the whole element, do not just reset and leave. The immersion circuit itself — 2.5 mm² minimum on its own 16 A or 20 A circuit with a double-pole switch — is covered in unvented cylinders for the unvented case.

Unvented cylinders: what the tundish is telling you

An unvented cylinder under Approved Document G3 has, for each heat source, a control thermostat and an independent overheat thermostat (energy cut-out) that interrupts the supply at about 85–90 °C and needs a manual reset; and on the cylinder a temperature and pressure relief valve set at 90 °C that discharges through a tundish to a safe place. There is also an expansion relief valve on the cold inlet set to the cylinder's working pressure plus a margin (6–8 bar typically). Discharges distinguish the faults: hot water from the tundish during heating means an overheat — the T&P has opened because the control stat failed and the overheat stat did not catch it, or the overheat stat opened and the T&P followed; find the failed control stat and replace it, then test the overheat stat and the T&P valve manually (the test lever) and record it. Cold or lukewarm water that discharges intermittently, particularly when the cylinder is heating from cold, is the expansion relief valve dealing with a flat expansion vessel or a failed internal air gap, and is a pressure fault, not a temperature one. Work on an unvented cylinder's safety devices is for an installer with the G3 qualification (Building Regulations Approved Document G, paragraph 3.x on competence). See unvented cylinders.

Solar thermal and the blending valve

A solar cylinder may reach 85–95 °C on a sunny day; the controller is designed to allow it (some limit at 85 °C, some at 95 °C), and the cylinder's T&P valve is set accordingly. The safe outlet temperature comes from a thermostatic blending valve at the cylinder outlet, set to 55–60 °C, feeding the whole hot water distribution. A blending valve that has scaled or whose cartridge has failed passes unblended water: scalding taps on a summer afternoon with the boiler off. Replace the cartridge or the valve (£40–£150, 1–1.5 hours), and check the controller's maximum cylinder temperature setting.

Scald prevention at the outlets

Once the cylinder is back at 60 °C, the taps still deliver 55–60 °C, which scalds in seconds. In new dwellings Approved Document G3(4) requires a TMV limiting the bath to 48 °C; in existing homes with children, older people or disabled occupants, the recommendation is a TMV2-approved valve (BS EN 1111 for mains-pressure systems, BS EN 1287 for gravity) at the bath and basins, set to 41–44 °C at basins and 44 °C at the bath, and in care settings TMV3 (NHS D 08) valves are required. A whole-house blending valve at the cylinder set to 55 °C reduces the risk without a valve at every outlet but leaves the legionella control to the stored temperature. Price the TMVs as an option on the same visit; the customer who has just had a scalding tap usually says yes. See thermostatic mixing valves and thermostatic shower valve replacement pricing guide.

Charging the job

Job Time Parts Typical charge
Diagnose, measure, test stat, reset to 60 °C 30–45 min — £60–£110
Replace cylinder strap-on thermostat 30–60 min £15–£40 £70–£140
Replace immersion thermostat 30–45 min £10–£30 £60–£120
Replace immersion element (partial drain) 1 h £30–£80 £120–£220
Replace unvented control or overheat stat (G3) 45–90 min £30–£90 £120–£220
Replace T&P relief valve (G3) 1–1.5 h £40–£120 £150–£320
Fit TMV at a bath or basin 1–2 h £40–£120 £150–£300
Retrofit cylinder stat, 2-port valve, wiring centre, interlock on a gravity system Half a day £150–£300 £350–£650
Replace solar blending valve 1–1.5 h £40–£150 £130–£280

See plumber hourly rate guide and electrician hourly rate guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What temperature should a hot water cylinder thermostat be set to?

60 °C, with 65 °C as the upper limit. That is hot enough to control legionella in the stored water (HSE guidance: stored at 60 °C, 50 °C at the taps within a minute) without wasting gas or scalding more than necessary. Below 55 °C the legionella risk rises; above 65 °C the scald risk and running cost rise with no benefit.

Why is my hot water suddenly scalding hot?

Most often the cylinder thermostat has failed with its contacts closed, so the boiler keeps heating the cylinder until the boiler's own thermostat stops it at 75–80 °C. Other causes: someone turned the stat up, the stat is not making good contact with the cylinder, the immersion heater's thermostat has failed, or on a solar cylinder the blending valve has failed. Test and replace the thermostat; do not just turn the boiler down.

Is it dangerous if my hot water is too hot?

Yes. Water at 60 °C causes a serious burn in about five seconds and at 70 °C in under a second; children and older people are most at risk. On an unvented cylinder, an over-heating cylinder also means the safety devices are being relied on. Have the thermostat fixed promptly and consider thermostatic mixing valves at the bath and basins.

Why is water coming out of the pipe by my hot water cylinder?

If it is hot and happens while the cylinder is heating, the cylinder has overheated and the temperature and pressure relief valve has opened: the control thermostat has probably failed. If it is cold or warm and happens intermittently, the expansion relief valve is discharging because the expansion vessel has lost its charge. Either way it needs a G3-qualified installer; the tundish is doing its job by making the fault visible.

Can I just turn the boiler thermostat down to stop the water being too hot?

On a system with a working cylinder stat it will not help, because the cylinder stat sets the water temperature. On an old gravity system with no cylinder stat it will reduce the water temperature, but it will also make the radiators cooler and does not fix the missing control. The correct fix is a cylinder thermostat and motorised valve with boiler interlock, which Approved Document L requires when the boiler is replaced.

Regulations & Standards