Summary
A customer who finds water under the cylinder in the airing cupboard assumes the cylinder has gone. Sometimes it has: a copper cylinder from the 1990s in a soft-water area pinholes at the bottom and weeps rust-coloured water from under the foam, and a stainless unvented cylinder can fail at a weld after 15 years. Far more often the vessel is sound and the water is coming from something screwed into it or bolted to it. The immersion heater gasket on an unvented cylinder, the 2¼ inch BSP flange on a vented one, the compression fittings on the 22 mm connections, and the temperature and pressure relief valve are the usual culprits, and each is a £10–£60 part and an hour's work rather than a £1,500 cylinder and a day.
The unvented cylinder adds a layer that confuses the diagnosis. It has two safety discharges, the expansion relief valve on the inlet control group and the temperature and pressure relief valve on the cylinder, both piped to a tundish and then to a drain. Water dripping or running from the tundish is not a leak; it is the cylinder telling you that the expansion vessel is flat, the pressure reducing valve has failed, the thermostat has stuck, or the valve itself is scaled. The fix is the cause, not the valve, and never the discharge pipe. For the system itself see unvented cylinders; for a replacement see cylinder replacement and cylinder replacement pricing guide.
Key Facts
- Cylinder types — vented copper (open to a cold-water storage cistern in the loft, to BS 1566-1), unvented stainless steel or glass-lined steel (fed from the mains at 1.5–3.5 bar, to BS EN 12897, with G3 controls), and thermal stores; the leak points differ
- Vented copper life — 15–25 years; failure is pitting from the inside at the base, worst in soft, acidic water, and at the bottom seam. The foam insulation hides it until the water runs out underneath
- Unvented life — stainless cylinders carry 25-year vessel warranties; glass-lined steel 5–10 years with a sacrificial anode that must be changed. Failures are at welds, the immersion boss and the coil connections
- Immersion heater flange — 2¼ inch BSP on most UK cylinders, sealed with a fibre or rubber gasket; the gasket fails with age and with the element being changed; unvented cylinders usually have a bolted flange with an O-ring. Drips from the top or side boss run down the cylinder to the base
- Immersion heater element — a split element does not usually leak water; it trips the RCD. Scale on the element in hard-water areas (above 200 mg/l CaCO₃) shortens its life and overheats the flange seal
- Cylinder thermostat pocket — a dry pocket on most cylinders; a wet pocket or a thermostat screwed into a boss can weep at its thread
- Compression joints — 22 mm cold feed, hot draw-off, vent and primary coil connections; a joint that was made onto a dented tail, or that has been disturbed by a new pipe run, weeps and the water tracks under the insulation
- Drain cock — a type A drain cock at the base of the cylinder; the washer hardens and it drips; the hose nozzle cap is the giveaway
- Primary coil (indirect cylinders) — a leaking coil lets boiler primary water into the hot water (vented: the cistern overflows or the hot water turns discoloured; unvented: the primary system pressure rises or the hot water shows inhibitor); the cylinder is scrap
- Temperature and pressure relief valve — on every unvented cylinder, set to open at 90–95°C or around 7 bar (the manufacturer's rating); discharges to the tundish. Water from it means the thermostat and the high-limit cut-out have let the water get too hot, or the valve is scaled and passing
- Expansion relief valve — on the inlet control group, set at about 6 bar (or 8 bar on 3.5 bar systems); discharges to the tundish when the expansion vessel cannot absorb the expansion of heated water. A flat vessel is by far the commonest cause of tundish discharge
- Expansion vessel — charge pressure should match the inlet pressure, typically 3 bar; check with the water isolated and the cylinder depressurised. Recharge or replace (£60–£150). On a cylinder with an internal air gap (bubble-top), the air gap is restored by draining per the manufacturer's method
- Pressure reducing valve — a failed PRV lets mains pressure through to the cylinder; the expansion relief valve then discharges constantly
- Discharge pipework (D1 and D2) — the tundish must be visible, within 600 mm of the valve, and the D2 pipe sized and run per Approved Document G3; never cap, block or redirect it
- G3 competence — installation, commissioning and any work on the safety controls of an unvented cylinder must be by a person holding a G3 qualification and is notifiable under Building Regulations; a leaking cylinder is a chance to check the existing installation complies
- Condensation — a cold-feed pipe or an unlagged cylinder in a cold cupboard sweats in summer; clear water with no mineral staining, worst after a cold refill
- Legionella — stored hot water should be at 60°C with 50°C at the taps; a stuck thermostat that causes tundish discharge is also a temperature control fault. See legionella risk
- Time on site — immersion gasket 45–90 minutes with a drain-down to below the boss; expansion vessel recharge 30–45 minutes; T&P valve replacement 45–60 minutes; vented cylinder replacement 3–5 hours; unvented replacement 4–7 hours
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| Where the water is | Likely cause | Confirm with | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Running down from the immersion boss | Immersion flange gasket or O-ring | Dry tissue round the flange | New gasket; check the element and the flange face |
| Weeping at a 22 mm connection | Compression joint | Dry tissue on each nut | Re-make with a new olive; replace a damaged tail |
| Drip from the base, rust-coloured, under the foam | Shell pitting or seam failure (vented copper) | Strip insulation at the base; look for a green-black patch | New cylinder |
| Drip from the drain cock | Washer | Dry the nozzle | New drain cock or washer |
| Water from the tundish, steady drip after heating | Expansion vessel flat (unvented) | Check vessel charge | Recharge or replace vessel |
| Water from the tundish, continuous, even cold | Pressure reducing valve failed, or expansion relief valve scaled | Pressure gauge on the cold outlet | New PRV or valve; new inlet group |
| Water from the tundish, hot, steaming | Thermostat or high-limit stat stuck; T&P valve opening | Cylinder temperature; stat operation | Replace the stat and cut-out; T&P valve if scaled |
| Cistern in the loft overflowing; hot water discoloured | Primary coil leaking (vented indirect) | Inhibitor smell or colour in hot water | New cylinder |
| Clear water on the cylinder and pipes, no staining, summer | Condensation | Dry and watch after a refill | Lag the cold feed; insulate |
| Water tracking from above | Loft cistern, vent pipe, or a roof leak | Look above the cylinder | Fix the source |
Detailed Guidance
Diagnostic sequence
WATER UNDER THE CYLINDER
│
├─ Is it coming from the tundish? (unvented only)
│ ├─ Yes ──► SAFETY DISCHARGE, not a leak
│ │ Cold or warm, only after heating ──► expansion vessel flat
│ │ Continuous, even with heating off ──► PRV failed or ERV scaled/passing
│ │ Hot, steaming ───────────────────► thermostat/high-limit; T&P valve
│ │ Fix the cause. Never block the discharge.
│ └─ No ──► continue
│
├─ Dry the cylinder and all fittings. Tissue test each one.
│ ├─ Immersion flange wet ────────► gasket / O-ring
│ ├─ Compression nut wet ─────────► re-make joint
│ ├─ Drain cock wet ──────────────► washer
│ ├─ Stat pocket/boss wet ────────► reseal boss
│ └─ All fittings dry ────────────► continue
│
├─ Strip the insulation at the base (vented copper). Green/black pitting or wet seam?
│ ├─ Yes ──► SHELL FAILURE ──► new cylinder
│ └─ No ──► continue
│
├─ Vented: is the loft cistern overflowing / hot water discoloured?
│ └─ Yes ──► COIL LEAK ──► new cylinder
│
└─ Clear water, no staining, cold cupboard, summer? ──► CONDENSATION ──► lag the pipes
Finding the water before condemning the vessel
Water that reaches the floor has usually travelled. Foam-insulated cylinders carry a drip from the immersion boss at the top all the way down inside the foam and release it at the base, where it looks like a shell leak. Start at the top. Dry every fitting with a cloth, wrap a strip of dry kitchen roll round each, and come back in twenty minutes. A compression joint that weeps shows as a damp line on the tissue; an immersion gasket shows as a wet ring around the flange. Then strip the foam at the base of a copper cylinder with a knife, a 100 mm band all round, and look for the green and black patch that marks a pinhole. A copper cylinder that is sound at the base and dry at every fitting is almost certainly not leaking.
On a jacketed cylinder, take the jacket off. On an unvented cylinder with a plastic case, remove the top cover and the immersion cover; the connections are usually visible without stripping the insulation.
Immersion heater gaskets and bosses
The immersion is the most disturbed fitting on the cylinder and its seal fails most. On a vented copper cylinder the 2¼ inch BSP immersion screws into a brass boss with a fibre or rubber washer; a new washer, a clean boss face and the immersion done up with a proper box spanner (not a pipe wrench on the head) fixes most weeps. Isolate the electrical supply at the switch and check it is dead before touching the head. Drain the cylinder to below the boss: on a vented cylinder, tie the ball valve in the loft cistern, open the hot taps, then the drain cock; on an unvented cylinder, isolate the cold inlet, open a hot tap to release the pressure, then drain at the drain cock with the T&P valve lifted to let air in.
Unvented cylinders usually have a bolted immersion flange with an O-ring. Replace the O-ring, clean the flange face, and tighten the bolts evenly in a star pattern. A flange face that has been overtightened or corroded will not seal on a new ring; the manufacturer sells a flange kit. While it is out, look at the element: heavy scale in a hard-water area means a short element life and a hot flange, and a water softener or a scale inhibitor is the long-term answer. See limescale damage.
Unvented discharge: the tundish is a message
Water from the tundish is the system protecting itself and the question is why. Work through the four causes in the order of how often they happen:
- Expansion vessel flat. When the cylinder heats from 10°C to 60°C the water expands by about 2–3% (5–6 litres in a 210-litre cylinder). The vessel absorbs it; if its diaphragm has failed or its charge has leaked away, the pressure rises to the expansion relief valve setting and the valve dribbles into the tundish during every heat-up, then stops. Check the charge with a tyre gauge at the Schrader valve with the cylinder isolated and depressurised; it should match the inlet pressure (usually 3 bar). Water from the Schrader valve means the diaphragm has gone and the vessel is scrap. Internal-air-gap cylinders are restored by the manufacturer's drain-and-refill routine instead
- Pressure reducing valve failed. If the mains is at 5 bar and the PRV passes it through, the expansion relief valve opens continuously. A gauge on the cylinder's cold side, or on a tap, reads above the 3 bar rating. Replace the PRV cartridge or the whole inlet group
- Expansion relief valve scaled or passing. A valve that has lifted many times holds debris on its seat and dribbles constantly. Lift the test lever to flush it; if it still passes, replace it
- Overheating. Hot water or steam from the tundish means the cylinder thermostat has failed on, the high-limit thermostat (the manual-reset cut-out that should have stopped it) has also failed, and the T&P valve is opening at 90–95°C. This is a double failure of the controls and must be put right before the cylinder is used; replace the thermostat and the cut-out and test them. The T&P valve itself may need replacing after repeated lifting
All of this is work on the safety controls of an unvented system and should be done by someone with the G3 qualification. Record it on the benchmark or service record. Never reduce the discharge, fit a bucket, or pipe it somewhere the customer cannot see.
When the cylinder has failed
A pinholed copper cylinder, a failed seam, a stainless weld leak or a leaking primary coil all mean replacement. The decision at that point is like-for-like or upgrade:
| Option | When | Cost fitted (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Vented copper, same size, grade 3 | Vented system, cistern sound, customer wants the cheapest repair | £500–£1,000 |
| Vented copper, larger or faster-recovery | Family has grown; combi not an option | £600–£1,200 |
| Unvented stainless, 150–250 litres | Mains pressure 20 l/min and 1.5 bar or better; customer wants mains-pressure showers; loft cistern can go | £1,200–£2,200 |
| Thermal store | Multiple heat sources, solar, stove | £1,800–£3,500 |
| Heat-pump-ready cylinder with a large coil | Heat pump planned | £1,500–£2,800 |
A vented replacement is plumbing; an unvented replacement is G3 work and notifiable, with the discharge pipework to Approved Document G3 and a commissioning certificate. Measure the mains flow and pressure before promising unvented. See cylinder selection and domestic hot water cylinder sizing.
Pricing the call-out
| Job | Time | Typical charge |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnosis, tissue test, re-make one compression joint | 45–60 min | £90–£160 |
| Immersion gasket or O-ring, drain and refill | 1–1.5 h | £120–£200 |
| Immersion heater element and gasket | 1–1.5 h | £150–£260 |
| Expansion vessel recharge and test | 30–45 min | £80–£140 |
| Expansion vessel replacement | 1 h | £150–£260 |
| Inlet control group (PRV, ERV, strainer) | 1–1.5 h | £180–£320 |
| T&P valve replacement | 45–60 min | £120–£220 |
| Thermostat and high-limit cut-out | 45–60 min | £110–£200 |
| Vented cylinder replacement | 3–5 h | £500–£1,000 |
| Unvented cylinder replacement (G3) | 4–7 h | £1,200–£2,200 |
State on the quote that the cylinder is on a tissue test and that a shell failure found during the job changes the price. See cylinder replacement pricing guide for the full breakdown.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a leaking copper cylinder be repaired?
A pinhole can be soldered or a boss can be re-sweated by a cylinder repairer, and for a week it will hold. A copper cylinder that has pitted through in one place has pitted nearly through in a dozen others; the water that caused it is still in there. Replacement is the honest advice for a vessel over ten years old. A leak at a fitting, a gasket or a joint is a repair; a leak in the shell is a new cylinder.
Water drips from the tundish for a few minutes after the hot water heats up. Is that normal?
No. An unvented cylinder with a working expansion vessel should never discharge in normal use. A short dribble on every heat-up is the classic sign of a flat expansion vessel, and it will get worse until the valve passes continuously. It needs a G3 engineer to recharge or replace the vessel; the discharge pipe is not the problem and must not be blocked.
The immersion keeps tripping the electrics and there is water at the boss. Are they the same fault?
Often. Water that gets into the immersion head from a failed gasket, or a scaled element that has split and let water into the sheath, both trip the RCD. Isolate, prove dead, and replace the element and the gasket together; test the insulation resistance of the new element before refitting the cover. If the cylinder is hard-water scaled, fit a low-watt-density or incoloy element and discuss a scale inhibitor.
Do I need building control for a new cylinder?
A like-for-like vented cylinder is not notifiable. Any unvented cylinder, new or replacement, is controlled work under Approved Document G3 and must be installed by a G3-qualified person and notified to building control, usually through the installer's competent person scheme. The notification and the commissioning certificate are what the customer's home insurer and a future buyer's surveyor will ask for.
Could the water be coming from somewhere else entirely?
Yes, and it is worth looking up before looking down. A cold-water cistern in the loft above the airing cupboard with a failed float valve, a vent pipe that discharges over the cistern and splashes, a roof leak over the cupboard, or a shower on the other side of the cupboard wall all end up on the cylinder floor. Clear water that does not correspond to the cylinder heating or being drawn from is usually one of these. See cistern overflow.
Regulations & Standards
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document G, Section G3 — hot water supply and systems; unvented hot water storage systems, safety devices, discharge pipework D1 and D2, competent installer requirement and notification
BS EN 12897:2016+A1:2020 — water supply; indirectly heated unvented (closed) storage water heaters
BS 1566-1:2002+A1:2011 — copper indirect cylinders for domestic purposes; open vented copper cylinders
BS 3198:1981 — copper hot water storage combination units for domestic purposes
BS EN 806-2:2005 — specification for installations inside buildings conveying water for human consumption; design
BS 8558:2015 — guide to the design, installation, testing and maintenance of services supplying water for domestic use within buildings
Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999 — expansion and backflow requirements, WRAS-approved controls
BS 7671:2018+A2:2022 — IET Wiring Regulations; immersion heater circuits and isolation
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document P — electrical safety; replacing an immersion heater on an existing circuit is not notifiable, a new circuit is
HSE Approved Code of Practice L8 — Legionnaires' disease; the control of legionella bacteria in water systems; storage temperatures
Approved Document G — GOV.UK — G3 unvented cylinder requirements and discharge pipework
Unvented hot water systems — Hot Water Association — industry guidance on unvented cylinders, expansion vessels and safety controls
Water Fittings Regulations — WRAS — fittings and backflow requirements for stored hot water
Legionnaires' disease: the control of legionella in water systems (L8) — HSE — hot water storage temperatures
Competent person schemes — GOV.UK — notifying G3 work through a registered installer
unvented cylinders — how unvented systems work and the G3 controls
cylinder replacement — replacing a cylinder step by step
cylinder replacement pricing guide — pricing a replacement
hot water too hot cylinder thermostat — overheating and the thermostat
megaflo cylinder fault codes — common unvented fault patterns by symptom
no hot water — when the cylinder is dry rather than wet