Summary
Cracked and missing grout is the most visible defect on a tiled surface and the one customers notice first, so it generates a steady stream of "can you just regrout the shower" calls. The honest answer is often no, not without finding out why the last lot failed. Grout is a rigid cement-based filler with almost no tensile strength; it does not crack on its own. Something moved, something was wrong with the mix or the application, or water has been getting behind it. Regrouting over an unfixed cause puts the tradesperson's name on the next failure.
The three families of cause leave different fingerprints. Movement cracks are linear and selective: they follow one or two joints across a floor, open at doorways and perimeters, or run along the junction of a wall and a bath. Mix and application failures are general: the grout is soft, chalky or sandy to a fingernail across the whole area, it has shrunk back from the tile edges, or it has pinholes and a dusty surface. Water ingress failures are localised to the wet zones and often come with staining, efflorescence, mould behind the grout line, or a hollow tile.
This article gives a diagnosis sequence, the thresholds for deciding between regrouting and relaying, the right grout class for each situation, and the movement joint rules that stop the problem coming back. For the regrouting method itself see grout repair; for grout selection see grout types and selection and grout types; for hollow tiles see floor tiles lifting or hollow.
Key Facts
- Grout classification — BS EN 13888-1:2022 (replacing BS EN 13888:2009): CG1 standard cementitious, CG2 improved cementitious (with W for reduced water absorption and A for high abrasion resistance, so CG2WA is the usual quality spec), RG reaction-resin (epoxy). Specify CG2WA minimum for floors and wet rooms; RG for showers in heavy use, commercial kitchens and swimming pools.
- Cement grout is not waterproof — CG grouts absorb water; a "W" grout absorbs less than 2 g in 240 minutes under the test but is still porous. A shower is kept watertight by the tanking behind the tiles, not by the grout.
- Movement joints — BS 5385-3:2014 (floors) requires movement joints at the perimeter, at doorways and thresholds, over structural movement joints and where the substrate changes, and intermediate joints at 8–10 m centres internally (closer with underfloor heating or large areas with solar gain). BS 5385-1:2018 (walls) requires them at internal corners, at the junction with other materials and at 3–4.5 m centres on large walls.
- Minimum joint widths — BS 5385 recommends not less than 2 mm for wall tiles and 3 mm for floor tiles (5 mm for quarry and extruded tiles); narrow joints give the grout too little section to carry any movement and are a common cause of cracking with large-format tiles.
- Joint depth — grout should fill the joint to at least two-thirds of the tile thickness; adhesive left in the joint from a hurried bed means a thin skin of grout that cracks and lifts.
- Timber floors — deflection must be under about 1/360 of the span for rigid tiles, and the deck should be at least 15 mm plywood or 18–22 mm P5 chipboard overlaid with a 6 mm tile backer or an uncoupling membrane; grout cracking in lines across a timber floor almost always means deflection or a floating deck.
- Screed shrinkage — a sand:cement screed shrinks for weeks after it is walkable; the usual rule is one day per millimetre up to 50 mm thickness plus extra for anything deeper, and tiling a screed before it has finished shrinking cracks the grout along the lines where the screed curls and shrinks.
- Underfloor heating — commission and run the heating before tiling (usually a controlled warm-up and cool-down over several days), tile with a flexible S1 adhesive, and use a flexible grout; switch on gradually after tiling. Grout cracked in a regular pattern on a heated floor is thermal movement with no joints.
- Water:powder ratio — over-watered grout has low strength and shrinks; washing off too early or with too much water pulls the cement out of the surface and leaves a weak, sandy skin. Mix to the bag ratio by weight or measure, let it slake, and wait until the grout is firm in the joint before washing.
- Efflorescence — white deposits on the grout surface are soluble salts carried out by water moving through the joint; on a floor it points to moisture from below, in a shower to water getting behind the tiles.
- Epoxy grout — RG grouts are impervious, chemical resistant and do not crack from water; they are harder to apply (short pot life, must be washed off before cure) and do not solve movement, so an epoxy regrout over a flexing floor still cracks.
- Flexible grouts — polymer-modified CG2 grouts tolerate small movements better than CG1 and are the sensible default on floors and heated screeds, but they are not a substitute for movement joints.
- Sealant at junctions — the bath/tile, tray/tile, worktop/splashback and internal corner joints must be a sanitary silicone or a purpose-made flexible joint, not grout (see silicone sealant going mouldy or peeling).
- Dust — grout removal with a power tool produces respirable crystalline silica; use on-tool extraction and FFP3 RPE under COSHH 2002 (the HSE workplace exposure limit is 0.1 mg/m³ over 8 hours).
- Cost — diagnosis and regrout of a standard shower enclosure (about 6 m² of wall): 3–5 hours, £180–£350; regrout a 15 m² floor with grout removal: 1–1.5 days, £350–£600; cutting in movement joints to an existing floor and sealing: £15–£30 per linear metre; relaying a failed timber-floor tile job with proper deck and membrane is a new job, not a repair.
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| Pattern of failure | Where | Diagnosis | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Straight cracks along a few joints across a floor | Follows one line, often room width | Substrate movement: joist line, screed crack, board joint | Fix substrate or cut a movement joint on the line; regrout |
| Cracks at perimeter, doorways, thresholds | Edges of floor | Missing movement joints; floor expanding against walls | Cut perimeter/threshold joints, fill with sealant |
| Grout cracked in a grid on a heated floor | All over, regular | Thermal movement, no joints, rigid grout/adhesive | Add intermediate joints; flexible grout; correct warm-up |
| Grout crumbles/powders everywhere | Whole area | Over-watered, over-washed, wrong class, too thin | Rake out to 2/3 depth and regrout with CG2WA, mixed correctly |
| Grout shrunk back from tile edges, pinholed | Whole area | Over-watered mix; washed too early | As above |
| Grout failed along bottom course / around bath | Wet junctions | Grout used where a movement joint was needed | Rake out, fit backer rod if deep, sanitary silicone |
| Grout cracked at internal corners of shower | Vertical corners | Wall movement; corner should be sealant | Rake out, silicone or flexible corner profile |
| Grout failing in patches, tiles hollow when tapped | Localised | Tile debonded; grout carrying tile movement | Lift and relay hollow tiles, then regrout |
| Grout soft, dark, mouldy behind the line | Shower, wet zone | Water behind tiles; tanking absent/failed | Investigate tanking; may need strip-out |
| White deposits on grout, floor | Floor near perimeter or on screed | Efflorescence; moisture from below | Check DPM, screed moisture; regrout when dry |
| Grout cracking only where large-format tiles meet | 1 mm joints | Joint too narrow for the movement | Widen joints (relay) or accept and use flexible grout |
| New grout cracked within weeks on a new timber floor | Lines along board joints | Floor deflection; no uncoupling layer | Relay with correct deck and membrane |
Detailed Guidance
Diagnosis: read the pattern
GROUT FAILURE — DIAGNOSIS
│
├─ 1. Is the failure in LINES or EVERYWHERE?
│
│ ├─ LINES → movement.
│ │ ├─ Lines run across a timber floor along joist/board direction?
│ │ │ → Deflection. Jump on it. Does it bounce? Check deck spec.
│ │ ├─ Lines at perimeter, doorways, column bases?
│ │ │ → Missing movement joints.
│ │ ├─ Lines follow a crack visible in the screed (lift a tile)?
│ │ │ → Screed cracked/curled. Cut a joint on the line.
│ │ ├─ Lines at wall/bath, wall/tray, internal corner?
│ │ │ → Those are sealant joints. Rake out, silicone.
│ │ └─ Regular grid on a heated floor?
│ │ → Thermal movement; joints and flexible materials.
│ │
│ └─ EVERYWHERE → mix, application or product.
│ ├─ Soft, sandy, chalky? → over-watered / over-washed / CG1.
│ ├─ Shrunk from tile edges, pinholes? → too wet; washed early.
│ ├─ Too thin (adhesive visible in joint)? → not raked; regrout to depth.
│ └─ Fine but stained/mouldy in wet zones? → water behind; porous grout.
│
├─ 2. Tap the tiles around the failed grout. Hollow? → tile is moving; grout is
│ the symptom. See floor-tiles-lifting-or-hollow.
│
└─ 3. Wet area: is there tanking behind? Flood test the tray; check below.
Grout failure + water downstairs = a tanking problem, not a grout problem.
Take a key or a coin to the grout and scrape. Sound CG2 grout resists; a grout that scratches to powder has either been mixed badly or has been dissolved by water and cleaning chemicals over years. Then tap the tiles each side of the failed joint with the handle of a screwdriver. A hollow note means the tile is not bonded, and the grout is cracking because the tile rocks every time it is stepped on.
Movement: the substrate is the problem
Tiles and grout are rigid; buildings move. Timber shrinks and deflects, screeds shrink and curl, concrete creeps, heated floors expand and contract, and walls move at their corners. Tiling that is bonded rigidly across all of that movement will crack, and the grout joints are where it shows first because they are the weakest element.
On a timber floor, the deck must be stiff enough. The usual spec is 15 mm minimum plywood (WBP/exterior grade) screwed at 300 mm centres to joists at no more than 400–450 mm centres, or 18–22 mm P5 moisture-resistant chipboard, overlaid with either a 6 mm cement-based tile backer board or a polyethylene uncoupling membrane bonded with a flexible adhesive. A floor that bounces underfoot will crack grout no matter how good it is. Tiles laid straight onto a floating chipboard floor or onto old floorboards fail every time. Where the floor flexes, the fix is to strengthen it (additional noggins, a second layer of ply, or a backer board), and that means lifting the tiles.
On a screed, cracks in the grout usually mirror cracks in the screed below. Shrinkage cracks appear where the screed was tiled too soon or had no bay joints; curling at the edges lifts the perimeter tiles. Lift a tile on the crack line to confirm. If the crack is dormant (stable, no height difference), the fix is to cut a movement joint through the tiles and grout along the crack line and fill it with a flexible sealant or a proprietary movement profile. If the screed is still moving or is weak (powdery, hollow against the base), the floor needs relaying.
Missing movement joints are the single commonest cause on floors over about 25 m² and on heated floors of any size. BS 5385-3:2014 calls for a perimeter joint (a compressible strip and sealant, hidden under the skirting), joints at doorways, over any structural joint, where the substrate changes (screed to timber, for example), and at roughly 8–10 m intervals in both directions, reduced for heated floors and areas with large windows. The joint goes right through the tiles and adhesive to the substrate and is filled with a flexible sealant or a prefabricated profile, not grout. Retrofitting them to an existing floor is practical: cut the grout line out with a diamond blade, remove the adhesive to the substrate, fit a backer and sealant.
Underfloor heating adds thermal cycling. The screed should be commissioned (heated gradually to the design temperature and cooled again) before tiling, the adhesive should be a deformable S1 or S2 class to BS EN 12004, the grout a flexible CG2, and the heating brought up slowly after tiling, typically no sooner than seven days after grouting, in steps of about 5 °C per day. Grout cracked in a regular lattice on a heated floor that was tiled before commissioning and has no intermediate joints cannot be fixed by regrouting alone.
Walls move less but still move. Internal corners, the junction with ceilings, window reveals and the meeting with a bath, basin, tray or worktop are all movement joints under BS 5385-1:2018 and should be silicone or a flexible profile. Grout at these points cracks within a year and lets water in behind the tiles. Large walls over about 3–4.5 m in either direction need intermediate joints too.
Mix and application: the grout is the problem
Grout that fails evenly across an area has been let down by the person who mixed it or by the product chosen. The usual faults:
- Too much water. A sloppy mix is easy to push into the joints and easy to wash, and it produces a weak, shrinking, porous grout. Mix to the manufacturer's ratio (typically around 200–250 ml per kilogram, product-specific), let it stand for a few minutes to slake, remix, and use within the pot life.
- Washed too early or too wet. Sponging before the grout has firmed in the joint drags cement out and leaves a sand-rich surface that powders. Wait until the grout has lost its wet sheen and is firm to a fingertip, then wash with a well-wrung sponge in a diagonal motion, rinsing often. A second clean with a near-dry sponge removes the haze.
- Wrong class. CG1 grout in a shower, a utility room or a floor fails early. Specify CG2WA. Where there is chemical attack (commercial kitchens, swimming pools), heavy cleaning, or a need for genuine water resistance, RG epoxy.
- Too thin. Adhesive squeezed up into the joints and not cleaned out leaves 1–2 mm of grout on top, which cracks and lifts. Joints should be raked to at least two-thirds of the tile depth before grouting and before regrouting.
- Joints too narrow. Rectified large-format tiles laid with 1–1.5 mm joints look sharp but give the grout almost no section. BS 5385 recommends not less than 3 mm on floors. Narrow joints need a fine, flexible CG2 grout and still crack under movement that a 3 mm joint would absorb.
- Grouted too soon. Grouting before the adhesive has cured (24 hours for most standard-set, longer in cold conditions) traps moisture and lets the tiles move while the grout sets.
- Harsh cleaning. Acidic descalers and bleach-based cleaners used weekly for years dissolve cement grout. Advise pH-neutral cleaners.
Water ingress: something behind the tiles
In a shower, grout that is dark, soft and mouldy behind the surface, or that keeps failing on the lowest course and in the corners, is grout that has been saturated from behind. Cement grout is porous and wall tiles and adhesive are not a waterproof layer; a shower is kept dry by tanking (a liquid membrane or sheet system to BS 5385-4:2015 and the Tile Association guidance) over the plasterboard or backer board. Where there is no tanking, the board behind absorbs water, expands, pushes against the tiles and the grout crumbles. Flood-test the tray by sealing the waste and filling to 25 mm; check for water below; then check the wall by running the shower on the wall for ten minutes and inspecting below and behind. A shower that is wet behind the tiles is a strip-out and re-tank job, and regrouting is a waste of the customer's money.
On floors, efflorescence (white salt deposits) on the grout and a grout that keeps softening near external walls or over a solid floor indicates moisture rising through the slab, which means a missing or failed damp-proof membrane. Regrout once the source is dealt with, and consider an epoxy grout which is less affected by moisture, while recognising it does not fix the damp.
Regrout or relay?
Regrout when the tiles are sound and bonded (no hollow notes), the substrate is stable, the failure is mix/application or confined to junctions that should have been sealant, and the joint can be raked to two-thirds depth. Relay when more than about 10–15 % of tiles are hollow, when a timber floor flexes, when a screed is cracked and still moving, when the shower has no tanking and is wet behind, or when the joints are too narrow to hold any grout. Cutting in movement joints is a middle path for a sound floor that simply had none.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I just regrout over the cracked grout?
No. New grout needs the joint raked out to at least two-thirds of the tile thickness to bond and have enough section to survive; skimming over the old grout leaves a 1 mm skin that cracks within weeks. And if the cause of the cracking was movement or water, the new grout cracks on the same lines. Rake out, find the cause, fix it, then regrout.
Why does the grout keep cracking along the bottom of the shower and in the corners?
Because those joints are movement joints and grout cannot do that job. The tray and the wall move independently with temperature and load; the two walls of a corner move independently as well. BS 5385-1:2018 requires a flexible sealant at junctions between tiling and other materials and at internal corners. Rake the grout out, fit a closed-cell backer rod if the gap is deep, and seal with a BS EN 15651-3 sanitary silicone, or fit a flexible corner profile. See silicone sealant going mouldy or peeling.
Will epoxy grout stop the cracking?
Only if the cracking was caused by water and chemical attack on cement grout. Epoxy (RG) grout is impervious and very durable, but it is just as rigid as cement grout in a joint and it cracks or debonds when the tiles move. It also costs three to five times as much and is unforgiving to apply. For a floor that flexes or a heated screed without joints, the answer is movement joints and a flexible adhesive and grout, not epoxy.
Is cracked grout causing the leak into the room below?
Possibly, but not on its own. Grout is porous even when intact, and a shower that relies on grout to keep water out of the wall will leak eventually whether the grout is cracked or not. If water is reaching the ceiling below, there is a failed or missing tanking layer, a failed tray-to-wall seal or a plumbing leak. Flood-test the tray and check the upstand detail before blaming the grout. See shower leaking through ceiling.
How long before I can grout newly laid tiles?
When the adhesive has cured enough that the tiles cannot be moved: 24 hours for standard-set cement adhesives at normal temperatures, 3–4 hours for rapid-set, longer in cold or damp conditions and over non-absorbent substrates such as tile backer boards and membranes. Grouting too early traps moisture under the tiles and lets them shift while the grout sets, which cracks it along the joints.
Regulations & Standards
BS EN 13888-1:2022 — Grouts for ceramic tiles: requirements, classification and marking (CG1, CG2, W, A, RG); replaces BS EN 13888:2009.
BS EN 13888-2:2022 — Grouts for ceramic tiles: test methods (supersedes the BS EN 12808 series).
BS EN 12004-1:2017 — Adhesives for ceramic tiles: requirements and classification (C1, C2, S1, S2 deformability).
BS 5385-1:2018 — Wall and floor tiling: design and installation of internal ceramic, natural stone and mosaic wall tiling in normal internal conditions; movement joints at corners and junctions.
BS 5385-3:2014 — Design and installation of internal and external ceramic and mosaic floor tiling in normal conditions; movement joint locations and spacing, substrate requirements.
BS 5385-4:2015 — Design and installation of ceramic and mosaic tiling in specific conditions, including wet areas and showers.
BS 8204-1:2003+A1:2009 — Screeds, bases and in situ floorings: concrete bases and cementitious levelling screeds; drying and bay joints.
BS 8000-0:2014 — Workmanship on construction sites: general principles (the tiling-specific workmanship guidance formerly in BS 8000-11 is now consolidated into BS 5385).
BS EN 15651-3:2017 — Sealants for sanitary joints; the correct product for the junctions that are not grout.
Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002 (COSHH) — respirable crystalline silica from grout removal; HSE workplace exposure limit 0.1 mg/m³.
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document C — resistance to moisture, relevant to tanking of wet areas.
BS 5385-3:2014 — BSI Knowledge — floor tiling movement joints and substrates.
BS 5385-1:2018 — BSI Knowledge — wall tiling and junction joints.
The Tile Association — Technical guidance documents — movement joints, wet areas, timber floors.
HSE — Construction dust: silica — controlling dust from grout removal.
Mapei UK — Grout classification and technical data — CG2WA and RG product specifications.
BAL — Technical advice on movement joints and substrates — manufacturer guidance on joint spacing and timber floors.
grout repair — the regrouting method: removal depth, tools and colour matching.
grout types and selection — choosing between CG1, CG2 and epoxy grouts.
expansion and movement joints — where joints go and how to form them.
tile expansion joints — joint profiles and sealants for tiled floors.
floor tiles lifting or hollow — the debonded tiles that often sit behind cracked grout.
silicone sealant going mouldy or peeling — the junctions that should be silicone, not grout.
underfloor heating tiles — commissioning, adhesives and grouts for heated floors.
bathroom waterproofing tanking — the waterproof layer that grout is not.