Summary
A hollow tile is a bond failure that has not yet become a loose tile. Tiles lift in two patterns and they tell you different things. A single tile or a small cluster lifting, with the adhesive stuck to either the tile or the floor but not both, is a local workmanship fault: a tile placed on ribs of adhesive that never collapsed, a dry skin on the adhesive before the tile went down, a tile back not wetted or keyed, or a bit of dust. A whole area tenting up along a line, with tiles still bonded to adhesive and the adhesive still bonded to a layer of screed that has itself delaminated, is a substrate and movement fault: the screed shrank or the tiles expanded and there was no movement joint to absorb it, or the screed was weak at the surface, or the underfloor heating was run before the adhesive cured. The first is a two-hour repair; the second is a floor coming up.
Pricing and reputation both depend on diagnosis before repair. Tilers who lift and re-fix the hollow tiles on a floor that has a movement problem will be back in six months with the adjacent tiles hollow. Tilers who condemn a whole floor over one hollow tile at a doorway lose the job to the one who reads it properly. The tap test (a coin, a hard plastic mallet or a dropped ball bearing: solid tiles give a dull thud, debonded ones ring) mapped across the whole room, plus a look at the tile backs when you lift the first one, gives you the pattern. The pattern gives you the cause.
This guide covers diagnosis by tap pattern and adhesive witness marks, the five causes with their tests, the repair of individual tiles including matching grout, the conditions under which a floor must be relaid, and how to tile a replacement floor so it does not happen again, including the drying, priming, adhesive classification and movement joint rules in BS 5385-3:2014 and BS 8204-1:2003+A1:2009. For adhesive selection see floor tile adhesive and tile adhesive selection; for movement joints see expansion and movement joints; for screed drying see floor screed types and drying times.
Key Facts
- Adhesive coverage — BS 5385-3:2014 requires a solid bed with no voids for floor tiles (minimum 100% coverage in wet areas; in practice at least 95% with no voids larger than a coin); achieve it by trowelling with a 10–12 mm notched trowel, back-buttering tiles over 300 mm, and bedding so the ribs collapse. Dot-and-dab on floors is a failure waiting to happen.
- Adhesive classes (BS EN 12004) — C1 standard cementitious, C2 improved (higher adhesion, ≥1.0 N/mm²), F fast-setting, T reduced slip, E extended open time, S1 deformable (≥2.5 mm deflection), S2 highly deformable (≥5 mm). Use C2 S1 minimum on timber substrates, underfloor heating and large-format or porcelain; S2 on heated anhydrite and floating floors.
- Porcelain — absorbs under 0.5% water, so standard adhesives do not grip it; use a C2 adhesive and back-butter.
- Sand and cement screed drying — approximately 1 day per mm for the first 50 mm, then 2 days per mm beyond; a 65 mm screed needs about 80 days in good conditions; test to 75% RH (BS 8203 hygrometer method) before tiling.
- Anhydrite (calcium sulphate) screed — must be below 75% RH or 0.5% moisture content (carbide method); laitance must be mechanically removed by sanding; must be primed with a gypsum-compatible primer; cement-based adhesive on unprimed anhydrite forms ettringite and the bond fails within months.
- Screed strength — BS 8204-1 soundness test (BRE screed tester) categories A, B and C; a screed that crumbles under a 4 kg drop hammer or scratches easily with a screwdriver is too weak to tile.
- Movement joints (BS 5385-3) — at the perimeter of the floor, over any structural movement joint, at changes of substrate (screed to timber), around columns, at doorways between rooms, and intermediate joints at 8–10 m centres internally (closer for heated floors and in areas of direct sunlight); the joint must go through the tile and adhesive down to the screed, 6–10 mm wide, filled with a flexible sealant or a prefabricated movement joint strip, never grout.
- Underfloor heating — the screed must be commissioned (heated gradually to its working temperature and cooled) BEFORE tiling to drive out shrinkage, then switched off for at least 48 hours before tiling and not switched on until 7–14 days after grouting, raised 5 °C per day.
- Timber substrates — a floor to be tiled directly must be at least 15 mm WBP or marine plywood screwed at 300 mm centres to joists at 400 mm maximum centres, primed, and deflection under load must be under L/360; tongue-and-groove chipboard is not a tiling substrate without an overlay or a decoupling membrane.
- Decoupling membranes — polyethylene matting bonded to the substrate with the tiles bonded to it, isolating the tile from substrate movement; the standard answer on timber, anhydrite and cracked screeds.
- Substrate flatness — SR2 (5 mm under a 2 m straight edge) is the normal requirement for a tiled floor under BS 8204-1; worse than SR3 (10 mm) needs levelling compound first.
- Dust, curing compounds and contamination — a screed with a surface curing compound, laitance, plaster splashes or dust will not bond; vacuum, mechanically prepare, and prime with the adhesive manufacturer's primer.
- Adhesive skinning — cementitious adhesive forms a skin in 10–30 minutes depending on conditions; a tile placed on skinned adhesive sits on it rather than in it. Spread no more than can be tiled in 15–20 minutes.
- Tap test — tap each tile at centre and corners with a hard object; solid gives a dull, dead note, hollow rings; mark hollows with chalk and look for a pattern.
- Tenting — tiles lifting along a ridge, often diagonally or at the centre of the room, is compressive stress from screed shrinkage or tile expansion with no movement joint.
- Repair threshold — isolated hollows under 10–15% of the floor with a local cause can be re-fixed individually; hollows in a pattern, tenting, or a delaminating screed mean relaying the affected area over a prepared substrate.
- Costs — re-fixing an individual tile including grout match £60–£120 (one hour plus materials); a 10 m² bathroom relaid including removing old tiles and preparing the substrate £900–£1,800; see floor tiling pricing guide.
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| Tap pattern and witness marks | Cause | Confirming test | Repair |
|---|---|---|---|
| One tile or a few random tiles hollow; adhesive ribs visible on screed, tile back clean | Insufficient coverage; dot-and-dab or uncollapsed ribs | Lift tile: ribs or dabs with bare screed between | Lift, clean, re-fix on solid bed |
| Tile back clean, adhesive smooth and shiny on floor | Adhesive skinned before tile placed | Lift tile: skinned, glossy adhesive surface | Lift, scrape, re-fix with fresh adhesive |
| Adhesive bonded to tile, screed surface came away with it | Weak or dusty screed surface; laitance | Scratch screed with screwdriver: crumbles or dusts | Remove weak layer, prime, re-tile; or relay with membrane |
| Adhesive bonded to tile, screed sound, powdery white deposit between | Anhydrite screed, no primer or laitance left on; ettringite | Confirm screed type (pours smooth, grey-white, often pumped) | Relay: sand, prime, gypsum-compatible adhesive or membrane |
| Hollows in a diagonal or central ridge; tiles lifting together; grout cracked in line | No movement joints; screed shrinkage or thermal expansion | Check perimeter and room-size joints; look at doorways | Relay area with movement joints at perimeter and 8–10 m |
| Hollows across heated floor; grout cracking | Heating run too soon, or S1/S2 adhesive not used | Ask commissioning history; check adhesive bag/data | Relay with C2 S1/S2 and correct commissioning |
| Hollows on timber floor; grout cracking at joints | Substrate deflection; chipboard or thin ply; no membrane | Bounce test; check ply thickness and fixings | Overlay 15 mm ply or decoupling membrane, relay |
| Hollows at doorway only | Substrate change with no joint; traffic loading | Tap either side of threshold | Cut movement joint; re-fix tiles |
| Hollows along one wall | Perimeter joint missing; tiles tight to wall or pipe | Check gap at skirting/pipe | Cut perimeter joint, re-fix tiles |
| Large-format tiles hollow at centre | Not back-buttered; lippage from uneven bed | Lift: bare centre on tile back | Re-fix with back-buttering and larger trowel |
Detailed Guidance
Diagnosis: tap the whole floor, then lift one tile
Start with the tap test over the entire floor, not just the tile the customer points at, marking every hollow with chalk. Note the pattern: random singles, clusters at edges or doorways, a line or ridge, or a whole area. Then lift the worst tile (a grout rake around it, a wide bolster at the edge, protect the neighbours) and read the back of the tile and the floor beneath:
HOLLOW TILE — READ THE WITNESS MARKS
│
├─ Tile back CLEAN, adhesive on floor shows RIBS/DABS with bare screed between
│ └─ Coverage failure. Local. Re-fix tile(s) on solid bed.
│
├─ Tile back CLEAN, adhesive on floor SMOOTH, glossy or dusty
│ └─ Skinned adhesive or dust. Local. Re-fix.
│
├─ Adhesive on TILE, floor surface came away with it (screed stuck to adhesive)
│ ├─ Screed crumbly/dusty when scratched ──> Weak screed/laitance. Area or whole-floor.
│ └─ White powdery layer, screed smooth and pale ──> Anhydrite + cement adhesive. Whole-floor.
│
├─ Adhesive on TILE AND floor, clean break between them
│ └─ Adhesive failed in itself (wrong class, over-watered, past pot life). Check pattern.
│
├─ Adhesive intact, SCREED cracked beneath or delaminated from slab
│ └─ Screed failure or structural movement. Engineer/whole-floor.
│
└─ Tiles lifting in a RIDGE with adhesive and screed top layer attached
└─ Compression failure: no movement joints. Relay area with joints.
Ask the customer when the floor was laid, whether there is underfloor heating and when it was first switched on, and what is under the tiles (concrete, screed, boards). The history is often diagnostic on its own: a floor tiled "two weeks after the screed went in" or heated "the day after grouting" has told you the cause.
Cause 1: adhesive coverage
The commonest cause of isolated hollows. BS 5385-3:2014 requires floor tiles to be fully bedded with no voids. Ribs from a notched trowel must be collapsed by pressing and sliding the tile; tiles larger than 300 mm should be back-buttered with a thin skim so the two layers merge; the trowel size must suit the tile (10 mm notched for 300 mm tiles, 12 mm or a half-moon trowel for 600 mm and over). Dabs or spots of adhesive (dot-and-dab) on a floor leave a tile supported on islands; traffic flexes the tile between them, the bond breaks at each dab, and the tile rings hollow and eventually cracks. Confirm by lifting: bare screed between adhesive ridges or dabs is the witness mark.
Repair is local. Lift the hollow tiles, scrape the floor back to the screed, vacuum, prime if the manufacturer requires it, and re-fix each tile on a full bed with back-buttering, then re-grout to match (see below).
Cause 2: the screed was not ready
Sand and cement screed shrinks as it dries. If tiles are bonded while it is still shrinking, the tile layer and the screed fight, and either the adhesive bond or the screed surface loses. The rule of thumb is one day per millimetre of thickness up to 50 mm and two days per millimetre above that, in a heated, ventilated building; a 75 mm screed can need four months. Test with a hygrometer box sealed to the surface for 72 hours (BS 8203 method): tile at or below 75% RH.
Anhydrite screeds add a chemical failure. Calcium sulphate reacts with the cement in standard adhesives to form ettringite, an expansive mineral that grows between the adhesive and the screed and breaks the bond in months. The laitance (a weak, powdery surface layer left as the screed dries) must be sanded off, the screed must be at or below 75% RH or 0.5% moisture (carbide bomb test), and a gypsum-compatible primer applied before a cementitious adhesive, or a gypsum-based adhesive used. Hollows across an anhydrite floor with white powder between tile and screed are the signature. The repair is a relay: lift everything, sand to sound screed, prime correctly, retile.
A weak screed (poor mix, too much water, inadequate compaction, frost during curing) fails at its surface under the adhesive. Scratch it with a screwdriver: sound screed resists; weak screed scores deeply or dusts. The BRE screed tester drop-hammer test to BS 8204-1 categorises it formally. A weak surface layer can sometimes be ground off to sound material; a weak screed throughout is replaced.
Cause 3: no movement joints
Tiles and screed expand and contract with temperature and moisture at different rates. BS 5385-3:2014 requires movement joints at the perimeter of every tiled floor (behind the skirting is acceptable), over structural joints in the slab, where the substrate changes (screed to timber, old slab to new), around columns and fixed obstructions, at doorways between rooms, and as intermediate joints at 8–10 m centres (closer, typically 5–6 m, over underfloor heating and in sunlit areas such as conservatories). A tiled floor with grout hard against the walls, through doorways and across a 12 m open-plan kitchen has nowhere for the stress to go. The classic result is tenting: a ridge of tiles lifting together, often diagonally, with the adhesive and the top skin of screed still attached, and grout cracked in a straight line. Confirm by checking the perimeter: grout or tile tight against the wall with no gap is the witness mark.
A floor that has tented cannot be fixed by re-sticking the lifted tiles. The compressive stress is still there. The repair is to lift the affected area (and often the whole floor), cut movement joints in the right places, and relay. Where the rest of the floor is sound and the problem is a single missing joint (at a doorway, or along one wall), a joint can be cut with a diamond blade through tile and adhesive to the screed, filled with a flexible sealant, and the local hollows re-fixed.
Cause 4: a substrate that moves
Timber floors deflect. A tile is rigid and its cementitious adhesive is nearly so; a few millimetres of deflection in the boards beneath it breaks the bond at every step. Tongue-and-groove chipboard is not a tiling substrate: it moves at the joints, swells with moisture and the adhesive does not bond to its surface. Plywood under 15 mm flexes between joists at 400 mm centres. A floating floor (laminate or engineered boards on underlay) is never tiled over.
The correct build-up is 15 mm minimum WBP or marine plywood screwed at 300 mm centres across the whole area (not just to joists), with the joists stiffened to limit deflection to L/360 and noggins under board joints, primed, and tiled with a C2 S1 adhesive; or, better, a decoupling membrane bonded to the prepared boards with the tiles bonded to the membrane, which isolates the tiles from substrate movement. On floors that have failed, the witness mark is cracked grout along the lines of the board joints and hollows that spread as the floor is walked. Repair is relaying over the corrected substrate.
Underfloor heating is a special case of movement. The screed should be commissioned (heated slowly to working temperature and held, then cooled) before tiling so that its thermal shrinkage happens first, then switched off at least 48 hours before tiling and left off for 7–14 days after grouting, then raised at 5 °C per day. Tiling an uncommissioned heated screed, or firing the heating up the next day to dry the adhesive, is a common cause of widespread hollows. Deformable S1 or S2 adhesive and closer movement joints are mandatory on heated floors.
Cause 5: the wrong adhesive or bad mixing
A C1 adhesive on porcelain, timber, heating or large format, a wall (D class) adhesive on a floor, over-watered or past-pot-life adhesive, or adhesive spread so far ahead that it skinned: each leaves a clean break between tile and bed. Check the empty bags if the customer has them, or ask the original tiler, and match the class to the substrate as in Key Facts.
Repairing individual tiles and matching grout
For local hollows with a local cause:
- Rake the grout around the tile with a grout rake or oscillating tool to the full depth.
- Lift the tile from the centre outward with a bolster and mallet if it is coming up whole, or drill a 6 mm hole at the centre and crack it out from there if it is bonded in places. Protect the neighbours with card.
- Scrape the old adhesive back to the screed with a bolster or a diamond cup wheel; vacuum; prime if required by the adhesive data sheet.
- Check the replacement tile sits at the same height dry; adjust the bed thickness, not the tile.
- Spread adhesive on the floor with the correct trowel and back-butter the tile; press and slide to collapse the ribs; check level with the neighbours; clean the joints.
- After 24 hours (or the adhesive's stated time), grout. Old grout has aged; take a sample to the merchant, mix a small test batch and let it dry fully before committing, or re-grout the whole room if the customer wants a perfect match.
Allow one hour for the first tile and 20–30 minutes for each additional one, plus a return visit to grout. Price it as a half-day minimum.
When to relay rather than repair
Relay if any of these apply: more than 10–15% of tiles ring hollow; the hollows form a line, ridge or area rather than random singles; the screed surface comes away with the adhesive; the screed is anhydrite tiled with cement adhesive and no primer; there are no movement joints on a floor over about 20 m² or over underfloor heating; the substrate is chipboard, thin ply or floating; or the screed itself is cracked or delaminated from the slab. Explain to the customer that re-fixing hollow tiles on a floor with any of these faults is a temporary repair, and quote both options in writing so the choice is theirs. For relaying costs see floor tiling pricing guide and tile replacement pricing guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a hollow-sounding tile always a problem?
Not immediately, but it is a bond failure. A tile that rings hollow at one corner and is otherwise solid may stay in place for years; a tile hollow over most of its area will crack under a point load or lift when the grout around it fails. Map the floor: a handful of random hollows is a repair; a pattern is a diagnosis. In a wet room, any hollow tile is a leak path and should be re-fixed.
How long should a screed dry before tiling?
Sand and cement: about one day per millimetre for the first 50 mm and two days per millimetre beyond, in a heated and ventilated building, so a 65 mm screed needs roughly 80 days; verify with a hygrometer at or below 75% RH. Anhydrite: typically 1 mm per day to 40 mm and slower after, and it must be below 75% RH or 0.5% moisture, sanded and primed. Fast-drying modified screeds can be tiled in days; follow the manufacturer's data. Never tile to a calendar date without a test.
Do I really need movement joints in a domestic floor?
Yes. BS 5385-3:2014 requires a perimeter joint on every tiled floor (which can sit behind the skirting), joints at doorways and at every substrate change, and intermediate joints at 8–10 m centres (closer over heating). A 4 m × 5 m kitchen with the tiles finishing 5 mm short of the wall under the skirting and a joint at the doorway has met the requirement; a 10 m open-plan room with grout to the walls and no joints has not. The perimeter joint is the one most often missing and the one whose absence causes most tented floors.
What adhesive should I use on an underfloor-heated floor?
A C2 S1 cementitious adhesive as a minimum, S2 on anhydrite or where the manufacturer specifies it, with the screed commissioned before tiling, the heating off from 48 hours before tiling to 7–14 days after grouting, and movement joints at 5–6 m centres and the perimeter. Use a flexible grout (CG2 to BS EN 13888) as well. Dispersion and C1 adhesives are not suitable.
Regulations & Standards
BS 5385-3:2014 — Wall and floor tiling. Design and installation of internal and external ceramic and mosaic floor tiling in normal conditions. Code of practice (bedding, coverage, substrates, movement joints).
BS 5385-5:2009 — Design and installation of terrazzo, natural stone and agglomerated stone tile and slab flooring.
BS 8204-1:2003+A1:2009 — Screeds, bases and in situ floorings. Concrete bases and cementitious levelling screeds to receive floorings. Code of practice (soundness, surface regularity SR1–SR3, drying).
BS 8204-7:2003 — Pumpable self-smoothing screeds (including calcium sulphate screeds). Code of practice.
BS 8203:2017 — Code of practice for installation of resilient floor coverings (contains the hygrometer test method for screed moisture widely used before tiling).
BS EN 12004-1:2017 — Adhesives for ceramic tiles: requirements, assessment and verification of constancy of performance, classification and marking (C1, C2, F, T, E, S1, S2).
BS EN 13888-1:2022 — Grouts for ceramic tiles: requirements and classification (CG1, CG2, RG).
BS EN 14411:2016 — Ceramic tiles: definition, classification, characteristics, assessment and marking.
The Tile Association – Technical guidance notes — industry interpretation of BS 5385 (coverage, movement joints, underfloor heating).
The Tile Association – Technical documents and guidance — industry guidance on BS 5385 application, movement joints and substrates
BSI – BS 5385-3:2014 Design and installation of internal and external ceramic floor tiling — the floor tiling code of practice
BRE – Screeds, flooring and finishes — screed soundness testing and drying guidance
BAL Adhesives – Technical guidance on substrates and adhesive selection — adhesive classification and anhydrite screed preparation
Mapei UK – Technical documentation for tile adhesives — adhesive classes, screed preparation and underfloor heating guidance
Ardex UK – Guidance on calcium sulphate screeds — anhydrite preparation, priming and moisture limits
floor tile adhesive — choosing the adhesive class for the substrate
tile adhesive selection — C1, C2, S1, S2 explained
expansion and movement joints — where BS 5385-3 requires joints and how to form them
floor screed types and drying times — sand and cement versus anhydrite, drying rates and tests
moisture testing floors — hygrometer and carbide testing before tiling
underfloor heating tiles — commissioning and adhesive rules for heated floors
bathroom floor prep — preparing timber and screed substrates
floor tiling pricing guide — pricing the relay