Summary
A failed bead of bathroom silicone is one of the most common small jobs a plumber, tiler or bathroom fitter is called back to, and one of the most common things a customer complains about on a bathroom that is otherwise finished well. It also has a disproportionate consequence: a peeled bead at the bath or shower-tray junction lets water through to the floor and the ceiling below, and the first the customer knows is a damp patch downstairs. The call that starts as "the sealant has gone black" can end as a ceiling repair if the bead has also lost adhesion.
Mould and peeling are two different failures with two different causes, and it pays to tell them apart on the first visit. Blackened silicone that is still firmly bonded is a hygiene and ventilation issue: the sealant has done its job, but the room is holding moisture and the bead is carrying a film of organic residue that mould feeds on. Silicone that has lifted, cracked along the bond line or come away in a ribbon has failed structurally, and the cause is nearly always in the preparation or the joint design rather than the tube. Simply gunning a new bead over the top of either fixes nothing for more than a few weeks, because new silicone will not bond to old silicone and the moisture or movement that caused the first failure is still there.
This guide covers the diagnosis, the reasons silicone fails early, the right product for the job, a reseal method that lasts, and what to tell the customer about keeping it clean. It applies to baths, shower trays, basins, worktops, splashbacks and window boards. For sealant chemistry and which product goes where, see sealant types. For the room-level cause of mould, see condensation and mould treatment and prevention. For the downstream symptom of a failed shower seal, see shower leaking through ceiling.
Key Facts
- Mould on silicone is surface growth — on a sound bead, black spots are Aspergillus, Cladosporium or similar fungi living on soap and skin residue; the silicone itself is not rotting. If the spots are inside the translucent bead, the fungicide has been exhausted or the product never had one.
- Fungicide is time-limited — the biocide in sanitary silicone leaches out over roughly 2–5 years depending on cleaning and water exposure; after that, even good silicone can blacken.
- Classification — sanitary sealants are classified under BS EN 15651-3:2017 (sealants for sanitary joints), class XS1 (with fungicide, tested for mould resistance) or XS2 (without). Specify XS1 for wet rooms.
- Neutral-cure vs acetoxy — acetoxy (vinegar-smelling) silicone cures faster and is cheaper but can corrode metal, attack some plastics and does not bond well to many stone and acrylic surfaces; neutral-cure (alkoxy or oxime) is the safer general bathroom choice and is required on natural stone, mirrors and most sanitary acrylics.
- Movement capability — most sanitary silicones are rated to ±25% movement (class 25LM). A joint that moves 3 mm needs to be at least 12 mm wide to stay within that; a 3 mm bead at a bath that flexes under a full load will fail.
- Minimum joint size — a bead smaller than 5 mm × 5 mm has too little bulk to accommodate movement or to adhere properly; fill wide gaps with a closed-cell PE backer rod first rather than one deep mass of silicone.
- Bath fill rule — fill the bath (or load the shower tray) before sealing the perimeter so the sealant cures with the fitting in its loaded, lowest position; sealing an empty bath puts the bead into tension every time it is used.
- Silicone will not bond to silicone — new silicone peels off cured silicone. Every trace of the old bead and its residue must be removed, including the invisible film left on tiles.
- Silicone will not bond to wet or soapy surfaces — detergent, limescale remover residue, body oils, dust and moisture are the main causes of adhesion failure. Clean with isopropyl alcohol or methylated spirits, not washing-up liquid.
- Cure time — skin forms in 10–30 minutes; full cure around 24 hours for a 5 mm bead, longer in cold or low-humidity conditions. No water contact for 24 hours.
- Grout is not a sealant — any joint between different materials (bath and tile, tray and tile, worktop and splashback, internal corners of a tiled shower) is a movement joint and must be silicone, not grout, per BS 5385-1:2018 and BS 5385-4:2015.
- Ventilation target — Approved Document F Volume 1 (2021) requires intermittent extract of 15 l/s from a bathroom, or 8 l/s continuous; without it, silicone, grout and paint all mould regardless of product.
- Bleach does not cure the cause — household bleach kills surface mould but discolours and weakens some silicones and does nothing about the residue and moisture that caused it.
- Shower-tray and bath movement — an acrylic bath on inadequate cradling or a tray on a flexing timber floor can move 2–5 mm under load, far beyond what a thin bead tolerates. Fix the support, not just the sealant.
- Cost — a straightforward bath or shower reseal is 1–2 hours including cutting out and cleaning, £80–£150 regionally, £120–£220 London; a full shower enclosure strip and reseal including screen 2–3 hours.
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| Symptom | What it tells you | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Black spots on surface, bead still firmly bonded | Hygiene/ventilation | Soap residue, poor extract, water sitting on bead | Clean, improve ventilation, reseal if beyond cleaning |
| Black growth inside translucent bead | Fungicide exhausted or none present | Old sealant or non-sanitary grade used | Cut out and reseal with XS1 sanitary silicone |
| Bead lifting in a clean ribbon from one surface | Adhesion failure on that surface | Contaminated, wet or incompatible surface; sealed over old silicone | Remove all, solvent-clean, prime if required, reseal |
| Bead split down the middle | Cohesive failure | Joint too narrow for movement; bath sealed empty | Widen/fill joint correctly, fill bath before sealing |
| Bead cracked at bath-to-tile junction only | Movement | Bath or tray flexing on poor support | Fix support, pack cradle, then reseal |
| Pink/orange slime rather than black spots | Bacterial (Serratia) | Standing water, poor ventilation | Clean with sanitiser, improve ventilation |
| Silicone gone yellow or brown | Chemical staining | Acetoxy silicone reacting; cleaning products; UV | Reseal with neutral-cure, advise on cleaners |
| Bead sticky or never fully cured | Cure inhibition | Contaminated surface, out-of-date tube, very low temperature | Remove completely and reseal in warmer conditions |
| Mould returning within weeks of reseal | Residue left behind or ventilation not addressed | Old film not removed; fan inadequate | Strip again properly; check fan performance |
| Water under tray/bath but bead looks fine | Capillary path behind the bead | Tiles not sealed to upstand; grout cracked above | Check upstand detail and grout, not just the bead |
Detailed Guidance
Diagnosis: mould or adhesion failure?
SILICONE FAILURE — DIAGNOSIS
│
├─ Is the bead still firmly bonded on both sides? (Press a fingernail along each edge.)
│ │
│ ├─ YES → Mould/discolouration only
│ │ ├─ Spots sit ON the surface and wipe partly off → hygiene + ventilation
│ │ │ → Deep clean. Check extract fan (15 l/s). Advise on drying the bead.
│ │ │ → If still unsightly after cleaning: cut out and reseal.
│ │ └─ Spots are INSIDE the bead → fungicide gone / wrong grade
│ │ → Cut out and reseal with BS EN 15651-3 XS1 neutral-cure sanitary silicone.
│ │
│ └─ NO → Structural failure
│ ├─ Bead came away cleanly from ONE surface → adhesion failure
│ │ → Was that surface wet, soapy, dusty, or old silicone? Almost certainly.
│ │ → Is the surface acrylic, stone or a plastic that needs neutral-cure or a primer?
│ │ → Strip, solvent-clean, prime if the manufacturer requires, reseal.
│ ├─ Bead split THROUGH its middle → cohesive failure (movement)
│ │ → Measure the gap. Under 5 mm? Too narrow for the movement.
│ │ → Was the bath/tray sealed empty? Reseal with it loaded.
│ │ → Does the bath/tray move visibly under load? Fix the support first.
│ └─ Bead hard, cracked, chalky → aged/degraded or wrong product (acetoxy, UV)
│ → Strip and reseal with a sanitary neutral-cure product.
│
└─ ALWAYS: check for water BEHIND the bead (tray upstand, tile-to-wall, grout).
A perfect bead over a leaking upstand still leaks.
Why silicone goes mouldy
Mould needs moisture, food and time. In a bathroom the moisture is constant, so the two variables are the food source and how long the bead stays wet. The food is the thin film of soap, shampoo, body fat and skin cells that settles on every horizontal surface. Silicone at a bath or tray edge sits exactly where that film collects and where water pools last. If the room does not dry between uses, the film never dries either, and mould colonises it within weeks.
Three things make it worse. First, a bead with a flat or convex profile holds a line of water along its top edge; a properly tooled concave bead sheds it. Second, an extract fan that is undersized, ducted badly, blocked with fluff or wired without an overrun timer leaves the room at high humidity for hours. Approved Document F Volume 1 (2021) sets 15 l/s intermittent or 8 l/s continuous for a bathroom, and many 100 mm axial fans deliver far less than their rated figure once ducted. Third, cold surfaces: an uninsulated external wall behind the bath is where condensation forms first and where mould appears first, which is why the problem is so often concentrated at one end of the bath.
The fungicide in sanitary silicone slows this down but does not stop it, and it leaches out over time. A bead that was clean for three years and then blackened is behaving normally; a bead that blackened in three months points to residue, ventilation or the wrong product.
Why silicone peels
Adhesion failure, where the bead comes away cleanly from one surface, has a short list of causes and all of them are in the preparation:
- Old silicone left behind. New silicone does not bond to cured silicone, and a smear of old sealant invisible to the eye is enough. After cutting out the bulk, the surfaces need scraping with a plastic blade, treating with a silicone remover or digestant where there is residue, then wiping with solvent.
- Wet surface. Silicone will skin over water but will not bond to it. A tray edge that feels dry can still hold moisture in the gap. Dry with a cloth, then leave it, then dry again, or use a heat gun on low.
- Soap and cleaning residue. Many bathrooms are cleaned with products that leave surfactants or waxes. Isopropyl alcohol or methylated spirits removes them; washing-up liquid adds them.
- Dust and grout haze. On a new installation, grout haze and tile dust on the tile edge is the usual culprit. Wipe and solvent-clean after grouting, not before.
- Wrong product for the surface. Acetoxy silicone bonds poorly to some acrylics, natural stone and powder-coated or anodised metal, and corrodes brass and mirror backing. Several acrylic bath and tray manufacturers specify neutral-cure and some specify a primer. Check the fitting manufacturer's instructions.
- Mould release and protective film. New acrylic trays and baths can carry a release agent from manufacture. Clean before sealing even when the fitting is new.
Cohesive failure, where the bead splits through its own body, is a design fault. The joint is moving more than the sealant can accommodate. The classic case is a 2–3 mm bead at a bath edge where the bath drops 3–4 mm when filled and someone gets in. A 25LM sealant tolerates ±25% movement; a 3 mm bead can absorb under 1 mm. The cures are to seal the bath full so the bead is at its neutral position under load, to make the joint wider and deeper (minimum 5 mm × 5 mm, with backer rod in wider gaps), and to improve the bath support so it does not move in the first place.
A reseal method that lasts
- Isolate the cause first. If the bath flexes, pack the cradle and fix the legs and wall batten. If the fan is weak, say so in writing and quote for it. If the tray upstand is not sealed to the wall behind the tiles, no bead will stop that leak.
- Cut out all old sealant. Use a sealant-removal knife or a sharp blade angled away from the tile glaze and the acrylic. Pull the bulk away in a ribbon, then scrape the residue with a plastic scraper. Avoid metal blades on acrylic and on soft stone.
- Treat residue. Apply a silicone remover gel to any remaining film, leave for the stated time (often 2–3 hours), scrape, and repeat if needed. Alternatively a lint-free cloth with isopropyl alcohol and firm rubbing for lighter films.
- Kill any mould in the gap. A fungicidal wash into the joint, left for the stated contact time, then rinsed and dried. Bleach is a poor choice as it can leave residue and damage some surfaces.
- Dry thoroughly. The gap must be dry, not just surface-dry. Leave the room ventilated for several hours after cleaning, or use a hot-air gun on low, keeping it moving.
- Fill the gap if deep. Push closed-cell PE backer rod into any gap deeper than about 10 mm so the bead has a defined depth of 5–8 mm and a flat back to work against.
- Mask. Low-tack tape either side of the joint, set to give a bead width of at least 5 mm and typically 6–8 mm on a bath or tray. Masking gives a straight edge and makes tooling clean.
- Load the fitting. Fill the bath to overflow level, or stand in the shower tray while it is sealed if it moves under load. Leave the bath full until the sealant has skinned (and ideally for several hours).
- Apply. Cut the nozzle to the bead width at 45°, gun a continuous bead pressing it into the joint so it wets both surfaces, keeping the gun moving at a steady speed. Do not go back over gaps; fill them from a second pass before tooling.
- Tool to a concave profile. Within 5–10 minutes, draw a tooling tool or a gloved finger wetted with soapy water along the bead in one steady stroke, pressing it into the joint to form a concave surface that sheds water. Remove the masking tape immediately, pulling it away from the bead at a low angle.
- Cure. No water for 24 hours. Tell the customer in writing, and leave the bath full for the first few hours if possible.
Choosing the product
For baths, trays, basins and shower enclosures use a neutral-cure silicone classified to BS EN 15651-3:2017 class XS1 with a fungicide, movement class 25LM or better, and check it is approved by the bath or tray manufacturer for their material. For natural stone, use a neutral-cure sealant specifically marked as non-staining for stone; acetoxy silicone can bleed oils into marble and limestone. For worktops and splashbacks away from standing water a neutral-cure sanitary silicone is still the sensible choice. Avoid "all-purpose" or "frame" silicones in wet areas; they frequently lack fungicide and are often acetoxy.
Hybrid polymer (MS polymer) sealants are gaining ground in bathrooms because they are paintable, low-odour and bond well to a wide range of surfaces, but check the data sheet for mould resistance and wet-area approval before using one at a bath edge. Colour-matched sealants from grout manufacturers are useful for matching a grout line but check that the sealant, not just the grout, is sanitary grade.
Telling the customer how to keep it clean
The reseal will blacken again if the bead is left wet and soapy, so the handover matters. Three habits make the difference: squeegee or towel the bead and the bottom row of tiles after showering; run the extract fan for at least 15–20 minutes after every shower, with the door closed, and open a window when the weather allows; and clean the bead weekly with a diluted bathroom cleaner or a fungicidal spray rather than letting film build up. Avoid bleach and abrasive cleaners on the silicone itself. If the fan does not clear the mirror within 10–15 minutes of a shower, it is undersized or blocked and should be looked at.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I just run a new bead over the old one to save time?
No. Cured silicone has a low-energy surface that nothing, including fresh silicone, bonds to. A bead applied over old silicone looks fine for a few weeks and then peels in a ribbon, often taking water in behind it as it goes. The time saved is lost at the call-back. If the existing bead is sound and only discoloured on the surface, clean it; if it needs replacing, remove it completely.
The silicone is clean but water still gets under the shower tray. Is the bead the problem?
Usually not. If the perimeter bead is intact and bonded on both sides, the water is finding another route: a tray upstand that was never sealed to the wall before tiling, cracked or missing grout in the bottom course or the vertical corners, a screen channel that is not sealed on the inside, or tiles fixed to plasterboard that has absorbed water and let it track down behind the tray. Test by sealing off the drain and filling the tray with a couple of inches of water, then checking below; if it holds, the tray and waste are sound and the water is coming through the walls or screen. See shower leaking through ceiling for the full diagnosis.
Why has the new silicone gone mouldy after only two months?
Either the preparation left residue or moisture behind, or the ventilation has not changed. Mould that appears at the back edge of the bead and spreads forward usually means the gap was not dry or clean when it was sealed and the growth is coming from behind. Mould that appears along the top surface means the room is staying wet and the bead is holding a film of residue. Check the fan delivers something close to 15 l/s at the grille, check the duct is not kinked or longer than the fan can handle, and check the overrun timer works.
Should I use silicone or grout in the corners of a tiled shower?
Silicone, or a purpose-made flexible movement joint sealant. BS 5385-1:2018 and BS 5385-4:2015 treat internal corners, junctions between tiling and other materials, and the perimeter of a tiled area as movement joints that need a flexible sealant, not rigid grout. Grouted corners crack as the walls move differentially, and a cracked corner in a shower is a leak path. Colour-matched sanitary silicones from grout manufacturers make this invisible.
Is acetoxy silicone ever acceptable in a bathroom?
It is acceptable on glazed ceramic tile to glazed ceramic tile where there is no metal, stone or acrylic in contact and the product is a sanitary grade with fungicide. In practice a bathroom almost always has one of those materials at the joint, and the acetic acid released during cure can corrode chrome plating, mark mirror backing and etch some stones. Neutral-cure costs a little more per tube and removes the risk; for a job you do not want to come back to, it is the default.
Regulations & Standards
BS EN 15651-3:2017 — Sealants for non-structural use in joints in buildings: sealants for sanitary joints. Classes XS1 (with fungicide, mould-resistance tested) and XS2.
BS EN 15651-1:2017 — Sealants for façade elements; the parent standard whose movement classes (e.g. 25LM) are used across the series.
BS EN ISO 11600:2003+A1:2011 — Classification and requirements for building construction sealants; the source of the 25LM/20LM/12.5E movement classifications still quoted on tubes.
BS 5385-1:2018 — Wall and floor tiling: design and installation of internal ceramic, natural stone and mosaic wall tiling; requires movement joints at junctions and perimeters.
BS 5385-4:2015 — Design and installation of ceramic and mosaic tiling in specific conditions, including wet areas and showers.
BS 8000-16:1997+A1:2010 — Workmanship on building sites: code of practice for sealing joints in buildings using sealants (still current; partly superseded by BS 8000-0:2014).
BS 8000-0:2014 — Workmanship on construction sites: introduction and general principles.
Approved Document F Volume 1 (2021 edition, incorporating 2022 amendments) — Ventilation in dwellings: 15 l/s intermittent or 8 l/s continuous extract for a bathroom.
Approved Document C (2004 edition incorporating 2010 and 2013 amendments) — Resistance to moisture, including the requirement to protect building fabric from water in wet rooms.
Water Supply (Water Fittings) Regulations 1999 — not directly about sealant, but relevant where a reseal is part of a shower or bath installation.
Approved Document F, Volume 1: Dwellings — GOV.UK — extract ventilation rates for bathrooms.
Approved Document C: Site preparation and resistance to contaminants and moisture — GOV.UK — moisture resistance in wet rooms.
BS EN 15651-3:2017 — BSI Knowledge — sanitary sealant classification.
BS 5385-1:2018 — BSI Knowledge — movement joints in wall tiling.
The Tile Association — technical guidance — trade body guidance on movement joints and wet-area tiling.
HSE — Damp and mould: understanding and addressing the health risks — government guidance on mould in housing.
sealant types — silicone, MS polymer, acrylic and polyurethane sealants and where each is used.
shower leaking through ceiling — tracing a shower leak when the visible bead is not the cause.
condensation — the room-level moisture problem that makes bathroom mould persistent.
mould treatment and prevention — cleaning and preventing mould growth on finishes.
grout repair — repairing cracked and missing grout that lets water behind a sound bead.
bathroom waterproofing tanking — tanking wet areas so that sealant is the second line of defence, not the first.