Summary
Boiler Plus started life as a 2018 amendment to the Domestic Building Services Compliance Guide and it is now built into Approved Document L Volume 1 (2021 edition). It is a Building Regulations requirement, not a manufacturer's recommendation, and it is checked through the Gas Safe notification and the Benchmark commissioning checklist. An installer who fits a combi with a basic programmer and a dial thermostat and nothing else has installed a non-compliant system, and the homeowner holds a boiler that may be challenged when the house is sold.
The rules are simple once separated into layers. Layer one applies to every boiler: efficiency and basic controls. Layer two applies to combis only: one of four additional measures. Layer three, added in 2021, applies to the wider system: flow temperature, water treatment, radiator valves and zoning. Most of what installers get wrong is in layer two, because the four measures are not interchangeable in practice and because "smart thermostat" has a specific meaning that many smart thermostats do not meet.
This guide sets out each layer, what each of the four combi measures actually requires, how to prove compliance, the common non-compliant installations, and what the measures cost to add. It applies to England; Wales and Scotland are covered in the FAQ.
Key Facts
- Scope — gas-fired boilers installed in existing dwellings in England; oil boilers have their own minimum efficiency in Approved Document L and the same control requirements; new-build dwellings are covered by the main Part L provisions rather than the Boiler Plus combi measure
- Efficiency — minimum 92% seasonal space-heating energy efficiency under the Energy-related Products (ErP) Directive, which every current condensing boiler meets; the ErP label is on the data plate and in the manufacturer's declaration
- Time and temperature control — a programmer or timer and a room thermostat (or a programmable room thermostat) on every installation, wired so the boiler cannot fire when there is no demand: boiler interlock
- Boiler interlock — the boiler must be switched off by the controls when the room thermostat and any cylinder thermostat are satisfied; a thermostat that only controls a pump or a zone valve while the boiler keeps cycling on its own stat is not interlock
- Combi measure, one of four — (1) flue gas heat recovery system (FGHRS), (2) weather compensation, (3) load compensation, (4) smart thermostat with both automation and optimisation
- Flue gas heat recovery — a passive heat exchanger on the flue that pre-heats incoming cold water for the hot-water side; built in to some boilers, retrofitted as a separate unit on others; typically 300–500 mm of extra height above the boiler
- Weather compensation — an external sensor on a north-facing wall that lets the boiler modulate its flow temperature against the outdoor temperature; needs a boiler and sensor that support it, and the boiler's own controls or a compatible thermostat
- Load compensation — a room thermostat that communicates with the boiler (usually OpenTherm or a manufacturer's bus) and modulates the flow temperature according to how far the room is from the set point; an on/off thermostat, however smart, is not load compensation
- Smart thermostat with automation and optimisation — "automation" means the control adjusts the heating in response to occupancy or user behaviour without a schedule being set (for example geofencing or presence detection); "optimisation" means it learns how long the house takes to heat and starts the boiler at the right time to reach the set point for the programmed period; the thermostat must do both to count
- Manufacturer compliance statements — thermostat and boiler manufacturers publish statements confirming which of their products meet which measure; keep the statement with the job file
- 55°C design flow — Approved Document L Volume 1 (2021) Section 6 requires new and replacement wet heating systems to be designed so the flow temperature does not exceed 55°C where that is feasible, which in practice means checking radiator sizing against the heat loss at the lower temperature (see low temperature design)
- Water treatment — the system must be cleaned and inhibited to BS 7593:2019, which also calls for an in-line filter to be fitted on the return (see system cleansing inhibitors)
- TRVs — thermostatic radiator valves on all radiators except in the room with the room thermostat, when the boiler is replaced in an existing dwelling
- Zoning — dwellings with a total usable floor area over 150 m² need at least two independently controlled space-heating zones with separate time and temperature control; smaller dwellings need separate time and temperature control for space heating and hot water
- Hot water — a cylinder thermostat and timed control for stored hot water; combis control hot water directly
- Notification — the installation is notified to Building Control through the Gas Safe Register notification scheme; the Benchmark checklist records the controls fitted and the Boiler Plus measure
- Enforcement — non-compliance is a Building Regulations contravention; the local authority can require remedial work, and the installer's competent person scheme can act; a solicitor's enquiry on sale may ask for the compliance certificate
- Costs to add — weather compensation sensor £40–£120 plus fitting; OpenTherm load-compensating thermostat £80–£200; smart thermostat meeting both criteria £120–£250; FGHRS £400–£900 fitted; TRVs £15–£40 per radiator fitted
Quick Reference Table
Quoting a heating job? squote turns a 2-minute voice recording into a professional quote.
Try squote free →| Requirement | Applies to | What satisfies it | Common failure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 92% ErP efficiency | All gas boilers in existing dwellings | Any current condensing boiler | None in practice |
| Time control | All | Programmer, timer, programmable thermostat | Boiler on constant with a dial stat only |
| Temperature control | All | Room thermostat or programmable stat in a representative room | Stat in the hall next to a radiator with a TRV |
| Boiler interlock | All | Stat wiring that stops the boiler firing when satisfied | Thermostat wired to the pump only; boiler cycling on its own stat |
| One of four measures | Combi boilers | FGHRS, weather comp, load comp, or smart stat with automation + optimisation | On/off smart stat with scheduling only; weather comp sensor supplied but not connected |
| 55°C design flow | New and replacement systems | Heat loss calculation and radiator check at 55°C flow; boiler set accordingly | Flow left at 75–80°C factory default |
| Clean and inhibit to BS 7593:2019 | New and replacement systems | Flush or clean, inhibitor dosed, in-line filter fitted, recorded on Benchmark | No filter; inhibitor not recorded |
| TRVs | Boiler replacement in existing dwelling | TRVs on all radiators except the stat room | Lockshield-only radiators left |
| Zoning over 150 m² | Dwellings over 150 m² | Two space-heating zones with separate time and temperature control | Single stat on a large house |
Detailed Guidance
Layer one: every boiler
Fit a boiler at or above 92% ErP seasonal efficiency, which excludes nothing currently on sale. Fit time control and temperature control, and wire the boiler so that it is switched off when the controls are satisfied. On a combi with a programmable room thermostat that is a single device wired into the boiler's switched-live or OpenTherm terminals. On a system boiler with a cylinder, it is a programmer, a room stat, a cylinder stat and two zone valves (S-plan) or a mid-position valve (Y-plan) wired so that the boiler fires only when a valve is open, which is the interlock (see s plan vs y plan wiring explained).
Put the room thermostat somewhere representative: an internal wall at 1.2–1.5 m, out of draughts and sunlight, in a room without a TRV on the radiator, with the radiator in that room fitted with a lockshield or a TRV fully open. A stat in a hall by the front door, which is the classic placement, satisfies the letter of the rule and gives a cold house.
Layer two: the combi measure
Choose one, and choose it for the house rather than for the price.
Weather compensation suits a house that is heated most of the day on a system that can run at low flow temperatures: it lets the boiler drop the flow temperature on mild days and condense almost all the time. It needs an outdoor sensor on a north or north-east wall, wired or wireless to the boiler, and either the boiler's own controller or a thermostat that supports the boiler's compensation curve. A sensor left in the box, which happens, is not compliance.
Load compensation suits most houses with a single thermostat: the stat talks to the boiler and modulates the flow temperature down as the room approaches set point, instead of firing at full temperature and cycling. OpenTherm is the common open protocol; several manufacturers use their own bus. The thermostat must be compatible with the boiler, and a stat wired to the boiler's on/off terminals is not load-compensating no matter what it says on the box.
Smart thermostat with automation and optimisation is the measure most often got wrong. The thermostat must both adjust the heating automatically from occupancy or behaviour (automation) and learn the heat-up time of the house to start the heating at the right moment (optimisation). A smart stat that offers a phone app and a schedule does neither. Check the manufacturer's Boiler Plus statement and keep it. Many smart stats are also load-compensating when connected by OpenTherm, which satisfies the measure by a second route.
Flue gas heat recovery recovers heat from the flue gases to pre-heat the domestic hot water. It is built into a few boilers and available as a retrofit unit for others. It is the most expensive measure and the only one that does not depend on the controls; it suits a household with high hot-water use where the controls are already decided.
Whichever measure is chosen, record it on the Benchmark checklist. The Gas Safe notification does not itself ask for the measure, so the checklist is the evidence.
Layer three: the system in 2021
The 2021 edition of Approved Document L Volume 1 turned a boiler swap into a system job. Three things changed:
- Flow temperature. Design the system to run at a flow temperature not exceeding 55°C where feasible. For a replacement boiler on existing radiators this means a quick heat-loss check room by room and a comparison with the radiator output at the lower mean water temperature; a radiator sized for 75°C flow delivers roughly half its rated output at 55°C. Where the radiators are undersized, the guidance accepts a higher flow temperature as the feasible option, but the check should be done and the reason recorded, and the customer should be offered the radiator upgrades. Set the boiler flow temperature to the design figure at commissioning rather than leaving the factory default.
- Water treatment. Clean the system, dose inhibitor, fit an in-line magnetic filter on the return, and record it, in accordance with BS 7593:2019. Most manufacturers also make the filter a warranty condition.
- Controls on the radiators and the zones. TRVs on every radiator except the stat room; two or more zones with their own time and temperature control in a dwelling over 150 m².
The common non-compliant installation
A combi fitted with a wireless on/off thermostat and the programmer in the boiler, the flow set at 75°C, no filter, three radiators still on wheel-head valves, the outdoor sensor that came in the box left on the shelf because nobody wanted to drill the outside wall. Every one of those is a Building Regulations failure, and together they are a boiler that will not run at its 92% rating for more than a few minutes a day.
The compliant version of the same job: the same combi with an OpenTherm thermostat in the living room, the flow set at 55–60°C after a radiator check, TRVs fitted to the three radiators, a filter on the return, the system cleaned and inhibited, the Benchmark checklist filled in with "load compensation" ticked, and the thermostat's compliance statement in the customer's pack. The difference in cost is £150–£350 and an hour.
Proving it and pricing it
Give the customer: the Gas Safe notification (Building Regulations compliance certificate), the completed Benchmark checklist with the measure recorded, the manufacturer's compliance statement for the thermostat, and the commissioning figures including the flow temperature set. On the quote, itemise the measure chosen and say why; a customer who understands that the £150 thermostat is a legal requirement and a fuel saving does not shop it against a £25 dial stat.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Boiler Plus apply in Wales and Scotland?
Not as such. Wales has its own Approved Document L, which requires a minimum efficiency and time and temperature controls with interlock for replacement boilers but did not adopt the combi-specific measure in the same form; check the current Welsh Approved Document L for the position on a given job. Scotland's Building Standards Technical Handbook Section 6 sets its own efficiency and controls standards. In both, the 92% ErP minimum and interlock are good practice and the manufacturer's warranty conditions usually require similar controls.
The customer already has a smart thermostat. Can I reuse it?
If it provides load compensation when connected to the new boiler, or has both automation and optimisation, yes, and the manufacturer's statement will say which. If it is an on/off stat with a phone app, it satisfies time and temperature control but not the combi measure; add weather compensation or an FGHRS, or replace the thermostat.
Is weather compensation worth it on a combi that only heats for a few hours a day?
Less so than on a system that runs for long periods, because the saving comes from running at a low flow temperature for a long time. Load compensation delivers more for the typical intermittently heated house, and it needs no outside sensor. Weather compensation comes into its own with a heat-loss-matched system running on a near-continuous low-temperature schedule, which is also the approach that prepares a house for a heat pump (see weather compensation controls).
Is a system or regular boiler replacement also caught by the four measures?
No. The four-measure requirement applies to combi boilers. A system or regular boiler needs the 92% efficiency, time and temperature control, interlock, a cylinder thermostat and the 2021 system requirements (flow temperature, water treatment, TRVs, zoning). Fitting load or weather compensation on a system boiler is still worthwhile and increasingly expected by manufacturers.
What happens if a previous installer did not comply?
The dwelling has a non-compliant installation and the homeowner can ask the installer to remedy it or complain to the installer's competent person scheme. There is no obligation on the next installer to fix it unless they touch the system, but when the boiler is next replaced the whole requirement applies. If you service a non-compliant system, note it on the service record and offer the upgrade.
Regulations & Standards
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document L Volume 1 (2021 edition, in force 15 June 2022) — Section 6 heating and hot water systems: minimum efficiencies, controls, the combi measure, 55°C design flow temperature, water treatment, zoning
Building Regulations 2010, Schedule 1 Part L requirement L1 — conservation of fuel and power, including controlled services such as boilers and heating controls in existing dwellings
Ecodesign for Energy-Related Products Regulations 2010 (implementing the ErP Directive) — seasonal space-heating efficiency ratings and labelling
BS 7593:2019 — code of practice for the preparation, commissioning and maintenance of domestic central heating and cooling water systems (cleaning, inhibitor, filter)
BS EN 12831-1 — energy performance of buildings: method for calculating the design heat load (used for the 55°C radiator check)
BS EN 12828 — heating systems in buildings: design for water-based heating systems
Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998 — installation and notification by a Gas Safe registered engineer
Building (Scotland) Regulations 2004, Technical Handbook (Domestic) Section 6 — the Scottish equivalent
Welsh Approved Document L Volume 1 — the Welsh equivalent requirements
GOV.UK — Approved Document L: conservation of fuel and power, Volume 1 dwellings — the current requirements for heating systems in existing dwellings
GOV.UK — Boiler Plus factsheet (BEIS, 2018) — the original policy explanation of the four combi measures
Gas Safe Register — Building Regulations notification — how installations are notified and certificated
HHIC (Heating and Hotwater Industry Council) — Benchmark commissioning checklist — the record of controls and measures fitted
BEAMA — Boiler Plus guidance for installers — controls industry guidance on compliant thermostats
BSI — BS 7593:2019 domestic heating water treatment — the water treatment code of practice
heating controls — the controls landscape in overview
heating controls upgrade — upgrading controls on an existing system
weather compensation controls — how weather compensation works and when to use it
smart thermostats — which smart stats do what
low temperature design — designing for 55°C flow
system cleansing inhibitors — cleaning and inhibiting to BS 7593:2019
trv installation — fitting the TRVs the rules require
boiler installation — the installation itself