Summary
"It only leaks when it's really chucking it down" is the roofer's most common and least straightforward call. The customer has watched the ceiling stain through three ordinary wet weeks without a drip and then found a puddle after a storm, so they are sure it is "the wind lifting the tiles". Sometimes it is. More often the roof covering is sound and the water is coming over, round or through a detail that only fails when there is enough water to fail it: a gutter that cannot take the flow from a steep slope in a cloudburst and sheds it behind the fascia; a valley that backs up because the outlet is choked; a chimney whose brickwork is fine in a shower but drinks a day of rain and weeps through the ceiling at the breast; a lead flashing whose upstand is 50 mm short so splash in a storm clears it; an abutment with soakers missing so wind pushes water sideways under the tiles.
The diagnostic skill is to match the trigger — heavy rain, wind from a particular direction, prolonged rain, or rain after a dry spell — to the detail that fails under that trigger, then to prove it with a hose before quoting. This guide gives the cause by trigger, the inside and outside inspection sequence, the hose test method, the pitch and lap figures from BS 5534 that decide whether a slope is simply below its limit, the repairs with prices, and what to tell the customer when the honest answer is a re-roof. For tracing a steady leak, see pitched roof leak tracing; for the condensation that masquerades as a leak, see condensation vs leak diagnosis.
Key Facts
- Trigger: heavy rain only, any wind — capacity: gutters overflowing (blocked, undersized, wrong fall, sagged joints), valleys backing up (debris, corroded or undersized valley lining, outlet blocked), hoppers and parapet outlets choked, flat roof outlets blocked
- Trigger: wind-driven rain from one direction — exposure: tiles or slates below minimum pitch or with insufficient headlap on that elevation, missing or broken tiles letting wind lift neighbours, verge or eaves tiles without proper bedding or dry-fix, missing soakers at an abutment, underlay torn or absent at the eaves, roof window flashing kit wrong for the pitch, vent tile or soil pipe collar with a split boot
- Trigger: prolonged rain (a day or more) — saturation: chimney stack brickwork and pointing absorbing water and releasing it through the breast, parapet copings with failed joints or no DPC, solid walls above a lean-to, blocked cavity trays over a lean-to abutment
- Trigger: rain after a dry spell — cracked mortar: ridge, hip and verge bedding that has shrunk and opened, allowing water in only when it runs down the mortar face at volume
- Minimum pitches (BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 and manufacturers' data) — plain clay or concrete tiles 35° (some concrete plains 30° with increased lap); interlocking concrete tiles typically 17.5–22.5° (some down to 15° with special underlay and fixings); natural slate 20–25° depending on headlap and exposure (BS 5534 Table for slate: headlap increases as pitch falls — 75 mm at 30°+, up to 115 mm at 20° in severe exposure); fibre-cement slates 20–25°; a slope laid below the product's minimum pitch for its exposure zone leaks in driving rain by design
- Headlap — plain tiles 65 mm minimum (75 mm in exposed locations); interlocking tiles per the manufacturer (typically 75–100 mm); slates per BS 5534 by pitch and exposure; a lap that was never enough shows as a leak only when the wind pushes water up the lap
- Exposure zones — BS 5534 uses driving-rain exposure categories (based on BS 8104); the same roof that is fine in Hertfordshire leaks in Pembrokeshire
- Gutter capacity — BS EN 12056-3:2000 sizing for a design rainfall intensity (commonly 75 mm/h for domestic, higher for critical situations); a 112 mm half-round gutter with a central outlet serves roughly 80–100 m² of plan area at 75 mm/h; a long run with a single end outlet on a steep slope exceeds this in a cloudburst and overflows at the far end. See gutter downpipe sizing
- Overflow behind the fascia — water going over the back edge of the gutter because the gutter is too far below the tile edge, the tiles do not project 50 mm into the gutter, there is no eaves support tray carrying the underlay into the gutter (the underlay has rotted back 100 mm, the classic 1F felt failure), or the fascia has no drip
- Chimney flashings — front apron 150 mm minimum upstand and 150 mm cover down the tiles; stepped side flashings with soakers (plain tiles and slates) or stepped cover flashing over a secret gutter (interlocking tiles); back gutter 150 mm upstand against the stack and 225 mm up the roof slope; chased into the brickwork 25 mm and pointed or wedged; lead in Code 4 or 5 for flashings, Code 5 for back gutters; a short apron or an un-chased flashing leaks only when splash is high
- Abutments — a pitched roof meeting a wall needs stepped flashing plus soakers (or a secret gutter with interlocking tiles) and a cavity tray in a cavity wall above the abutment; a mortar fillet instead of lead is a wind-driven leak waiting for a storm
- Roof windows — the flashing kit must match the covering (profiled vs slate/flat) and the pitch; a kit for 15°+ fitted at 15° in a severe zone, or a window fitted without the recommended underlay collar, leaks in wind-driven rain; the drainage channel above the window must be clear
- Ridges, hips and verges — mortar bedding cracks and admits water at volume; BS 5534 requires mechanical fixing of ridge and hip tiles and verge units (since 2014/2015); dry-fix systems to BS 8612:2018 are the compliant repair. See ridge tile rebedding and dry verge and dry ridge systems
- Underlay — bituminous 1F felt perishes at the eaves after 30–40 years; breathable membranes to BS EN 13859-1 are the replacement; a hole in the underlay lets wind-driven water that passes the tiles reach the ceiling instead of draining to the gutter
- Condensation, not a leak — a ceiling stain that appears in cold weather regardless of rain, with a dry loft in rain, is condensation on the underlay or a cold-bridged ceiling; see condensation vs leak diagnosis
- Hose test — one person inside the loft with a torch, one outside with a hose; wet one zone at a time starting at the eaves and working up, 5–10 minutes per zone, never spraying up under the tiles from below the lap (that proves nothing); the detail that leaks is the one being wetted when the drip starts
- Access — a leak hunt on a two-storey roof is a tower or scaffold job; a ladder is for inspection of the gutter line only; Work at Height Regulations 2005, HSE INDG401 on ladders
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| Where the water appears inside | Trigger | Most likely cause | Confirm | Repair and typical cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ceiling at the eaves, along the outside wall | Heavy rain | Gutter overflowing behind fascia; underlay rotted back at eaves; no eaves tray | Watch the gutter in rain; look under first course | Clear gutter, re-fall, eaves support tray and fascia drip £150–£400 |
| Ceiling at the eaves, one corner | Heavy rain | Gutter run too long for one outlet; stop end leaking; downpipe blocked | Overflow at the far end | Add outlet/downpipe £150–£350; clear and reseal £80–£180 |
| Stain at the chimney breast, upstairs | Prolonged or wind-driven rain | Flashing short or un-chased; back gutter failed; stack saturated; pointing or cap failed | Hose each face separately; check pointing and cap | Re-flash £400–£900; repoint and cap £300–£700 with access |
| Stain on a wall where a lean-to meets it | Wind-driven or prolonged | Abutment flashing, no soakers, no cavity tray | Hose the abutment; inspect for tray weeps | Lead abutment flashing and soakers £300–£700; cavity tray £400–£900 |
| Stain below a valley | Heavy rain | Valley blocked or overflowing; lining corroded or too narrow; tiles cut too close | Inspect valley in rain | Clear £80–£150; re-line valley in Code 5 lead or GRP £500–£1,200 |
| Stain around a roof window | Wind from one side | Flashing kit, underlay collar, blocked drainage channel | Hose above and to the side of the window | Re-fit flashing kit £250–£600 |
| Stain mid-slope, random | Wind-driven | Slipped, cracked or missing tile; failed vent tile boot; nail sickness on slate | Loft inspection in rain: daylight or drip at the underlay | Replace tiles £100–£300; vent boot £120–£250; slate repairs £150–£400 |
| Stain below the ridge or hip line | Rain after a dry spell, or wind | Cracked mortar bedding; ridge not fixed | Inspect bedding; press the ridge | Dry ridge/hip to BS 8612 £400–£900 per run |
| Stain at the verge | Wind from the gable side | Mortar verge cracked; undercloak failed; no dry verge | Inspect verge | Dry verge £300–£550 per verge |
| Whole elevation damp in wind from one direction only | Wind-driven | Slope below minimum pitch or insufficient lap for the exposure | Measure pitch and lap; compare with BS 5534 and manufacturer | Re-cover with suitable tile or increased lap and underlay — a re-roof quote |
| Stain regardless of rain, worse in cold weather | None | Condensation | Loft dry during rain; humidity | Ventilation and insulation; not a roof repair |
Detailed Guidance
Read the trigger before you climb the ladder
Ask the customer four questions. When does it leak — heavy rain, any rain, only after a day of rain, only when the wind is from the sea or from the gable? Where does it show, and how long after the rain starts? Has anything changed — a new fence that funnels wind, trees cut back, a neighbour's extension, solar panels fitted, a roof window, gutters replaced? And has the loft been looked at during rain? The answers put the fault in a row of the table before you get the ladder off the van.
Inside first: the loft in the rain
If it is raining, go into the loft with a torch and look up, not down. Water tracks along rafters and underlay and drops where it meets an obstruction, so the stain on the ceiling is often a metre or more from the entry point and always downhill of it. Look for daylight (a missing or slipped tile), a dark wet line on the underlay (water running under the tiles above a lap failure), drips off the underlay at a batten (a tear or a nail hole directly above), wet timber at the chimney or an abutment (flashing), wet insulation along the eaves (gutter overflow or the underlay rotted back), and wet on the inside of a gable wall (verge or wall saturation). Mark the wet spot with chalk on the rafter and measure its position from the gable and the eaves so you can find the same spot outside.
Outside: the sectional hose test
With the roof dry, one person stays in the loft. From a tower or scaffold, wet the roof in sections from the bottom up: the gutter line and first two courses first, then the next band up, then each detail — valley, chimney, abutment, roof window, vent — on its own. Five to ten minutes per section, running water down the roof as rain would (never driven up under the tiles from below, which forces water past laps that rain never reaches). The inside observer calls when the drip starts, and the section being wetted at that moment is the fault. Test the suspected detail from each side separately: a chimney has four flashings and a stack; the leak is one of them. For a wind-driven fault, a hose cannot fully reproduce the wind; a leaf blower against a wetted slope is a crude substitute, but the loft inspection during the next storm is the real proof.
Gutters and eaves: the commonest heavy-rain leak
A gutter overflows for one of four reasons: it is blocked (moss off the tiles, leaves, a tennis ball at the outlet), it is too small or has too few outlets for the roof area, it has lost its fall or a joint has sagged, or the water is going over the back edge rather than the front. The last is the one that gets into the house. The tile or slate edge should project 40–50 mm into the gutter; the underlay should run into the gutter on an eaves support tray so that water that gets under the tiles still drains; and the gutter should sit so that water leaving the tile edge at speed in a cloudburst lands in it, not over it. On an old roof the 1F felt has rotted back from the eaves, the first course drains onto the fascia top, and in heavy rain it runs into the eaves and the wall plate. The repair is a run of eaves tray (£3–£6 per metre), a fascia drip or over-fascia vent, and a check on the gutter fall and outlets. Size the gutter to BS EN 12056-3 if the roof area or pitch suggests it is marginal — a long steep slope with one end outlet is the usual offender, and a second downpipe is cheaper than a new ceiling. See gutter downpipe sizing and roof eaves verge.
Chimneys and abutments: the prolonged-rain leak
A chimney stack is a column of brick standing in the weather with four flashings at its base. In a shower the flashings do the work; in a day of rain the brickwork saturates, the water moves down through the stack and emerges inside at the breast, often on the chimney breast wall below the ceiling rather than on the ceiling itself. Check the pointing, the flaunching, the cap or pot and whether the stack is capped or vented (a disused unvented stack holds water); check for a DPC tray in the stack (post-1960s stacks usually have one, older ones do not). Then the flashings: a front apron with less than 150 mm upstand or 150 mm cover; stepped flashings not chased 25 mm into the joints; soakers missing under a stepped flashing on plain tiles or slates; a back gutter with a short upstand or no welted edge, and the commonest of all, a back gutter that has split along the fold after decades of thermal movement. Lead to Code 4 (1.8 mm) for aprons and step flashings, Code 5 (2.24 mm) for back gutters and valleys; replace rather than patch, and do not bed lead in mortar. A re-flash is a day with access, £400–£900; repointing and a new cap with it, £300–£700 more. See chimney repairs and lead chimney flashings.
An abutment — a lean-to, porch or extension roof meeting a wall — fails in wind-driven rain where the flashing is a cement fillet, where there are no soakers, or where the cavity wall above has no tray so water in the cavity runs down behind the flashing and out at the ceiling line inside. The tray is the expensive one: cutting one in is brickwork, £400–£900 for a short run. See lead soakers and cover flashings.
Pitch, lap and the roof that was always going to leak
Some roofs leak in driving rain because they were laid below the covering's minimum pitch or with too little lap for the exposure. A 1980s extension with interlocking tiles at 15° when the tile's minimum was 22.5°; a slate roof in the South West at 22° with a 75 mm lap where BS 5534 wants 100 mm or more; plain tiles at 30° on a dormer cheek. Measure the pitch with an inclinometer and the lap at three places, and compare with BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 and the manufacturer's data sheet. If the covering is below its limit there is no repair — fixing individual tiles does not change the physics — and the honest quote is a re-cover with a tile rated for the pitch, or the same slate at an increased lap with a suitable underlay, which is a re-roof of that slope. Say so clearly; a customer who has paid for three "repairs" to a 15° roof will not thank you for the fourth. See tile batten spacing by pitch and slate installation.
Ridges, hips, verges and the dry-fix answer
Mortar bedding shrinks, cracks and lets water in only when there is enough running down the face of the ridge or hip to enter the cracks. BS 5534 has required mechanical fixing of ridge, hip and verge tiles since the 2014 edition took effect, so the compliant repair is a dry ridge or dry hip system to BS 8612:2018, or a dry verge, rather than re-bedding in mortar. Prices are in ridge tile rebedding and dry verge installation pricing guide. A roof with one cracked hip can be re-bedded and clipped as a short-term repair; three cracked runs is a dry-fix job.
Roof windows, vents and penetrations
A roof window leaks in wind-driven rain at the top flashing where the drainage channel above the frame is blocked with moss, at the side flashings where the kit is for a different profile or pitch, or because the underlay was not dressed up and sealed to the frame with a collar. A vent tile or soil pipe collar leaks where the rubber boot has split in the sun. Both are half-day jobs: re-fit the flashing kit (£250–£600) or replace the vent tile or boot (£120–£250).
Writing the quote
State the trigger, the test, the finding, and the repair: "Leak at front bedroom ceiling occurs in heavy rain only. Hose test confirmed overflow at rear of gutter along 6 m of eaves; underlay perished at eaves, no eaves tray. Repair: fit eaves support tray and fascia drip to 6 m, re-fall gutter and add outlet at east end, replace 4 cracked tiles. Access by tower. Excludes decoration of ceiling." Exclude what you have not tested, exclude internal making good unless priced, and if the slope is below its minimum pitch say that the repair will reduce but may not eliminate wind-driven leaks and that a re-cover is the permanent fix.
| Repair | Time | Typical charge (incl. access by tower) |
|---|---|---|
| Clear gutters and valley, reseal joints, check falls | 1–3 h | £80–£200 |
| Eaves support tray and fascia drip, per 6 m | 2–3 h | £150–£300 |
| Add gutter outlet and downpipe | 2–4 h | £150–£350 |
| Replace slipped or broken tiles, up to 10 | 1–2 h | £100–£300 |
| Re-line valley, Code 5 lead or GRP, up to 4 m | 1 day | £500–£1,200 |
| Re-flash chimney, four sides, Code 4/5 lead | 1 day | £400–£900 |
| Repoint stack and renew cap | 1 day | £300–£700 |
| Lead abutment flashing and soakers, up to 4 m | Half to one day | £300–£700 |
| Dry ridge or hip, per run | Half to one day | £400–£900 |
| Roof window flashing re-fit | Half a day | £250–£600 |
| Re-cover a slope laid below minimum pitch | Per m² | See roof repair pricing guide |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my roof only leak in heavy rain?
Because the fault only fails under volume or wind pressure: a gutter or valley that overflows when the flow exceeds its capacity, a short or failed flashing that splash clears in a storm, a chimney stack that saturates over a day of rain, cracked ridge mortar that admits water only when it runs at volume, or tiles laid at too low a pitch or lap for the exposure so that wind drives water up under them. Ordinary rain simply runs off.
How do I find a roof leak that only happens in wind-driven rain?
Go into the loft during the next windy rain with a torch and find where water is actually entering — usually a metre or more uphill of the ceiling stain. Note the wind direction. Then, on a dry day, hose test that elevation section by section from the eaves upward with someone watching inside. Wind-driven leaks are usually a lap, verge, abutment or roof window detail on the elevation facing the wind.
Can a blocked gutter cause a roof leak?
Yes, and it is the most common cause of a leak that appears only in heavy rain. An overflowing gutter sheds water over its back edge onto the fascia and into the eaves, and where the underlay has perished at the eaves, that water reaches the ceiling and wall plate. Clearing the gutter, checking the falls and outlets, and fitting an eaves support tray fixes it.
How much does it cost to fix a roof leak in the UK?
Simple repairs — clearing gutters and valleys, replacing a few tiles, re-sealing joints — are £80–£300. Flashings, valleys and eaves work are £150–£1,200 depending on the extent and access. Where the roof covering is below its minimum pitch for the tile or the exposure, the permanent fix is a re-cover of that slope, priced per square metre, because individual repairs will not stop wind-driven rain.
Is a wet patch on the ceiling always a roof leak?
No. A patch that appears or worsens in cold weather regardless of rain, with a dry loft during rain, is usually condensation on the underside of the underlay or on a cold spot in the ceiling. Check the loft during rain before quoting roof work; the fix for condensation is ventilation and insulation, not tiles.
Regulations & Standards
BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 — code of practice for slating and tiling for pitched roofs and vertical cladding; minimum pitches, headlap, exposure, mechanical fixing of ridges, hips and verges, underlay
BS 8612:2018 — dry-fixed ridge, hip and verge systems for slating and tiling; specification
BS 8000-0:2014 and BS 8000-6:2013 — workmanship on construction sites; slating and tiling of roofs and claddings
BS EN 12056-3:2000 — gravity drainage systems inside buildings; roof drainage, layout and calculation (gutter and outlet sizing)
BS EN 13859-1:2014 — flexible sheets for waterproofing; underlays for discontinuous roofing
BS EN 12588:2006 — lead and lead alloys; rolled lead sheet for building purposes (Codes 3–8)
BS 8104:1992 — code of practice for assessing exposure of walls to wind-driven rain (exposure categories used by BS 5534)
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document C (2004 edition incorporating 2010 and 2013 amendments) — C2 resistance to moisture; roofs and penetrations
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document A — structure; re-covering with a heavier or lighter material is a material alteration requiring notification
Work at Height Regulations 2005 (SI 2005/735) — access for inspection and repair; HSE INDG401 on ladders and HSG33 on roof work
Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 — domestic client duties; roof work is construction work
BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 — BSI Knowledge — pitched roof slating and tiling code of practice
NFRC — National Federation of Roofing Contractors technical guidance — roofing technical bulletins and best practice
Lead Sheet Training Academy — technical guidance — flashing dimensions, codes and detailing
HSE — Health and safety in roof work (HSG33) — access and fall prevention
Approved Document C: Site preparation and resistance to contaminants and moisture — gov.uk
BS EN 12056-3:2000 — BSI Knowledge — roof drainage design
pitched roof leak tracing — the general leak-tracing method
condensation vs leak diagnosis — ruling out condensation first
gutter downpipe sizing — sizing gutters and outlets to BS EN 12056-3
roof eaves verge — eaves trays, fascia drips and verge detailing
felt underlay and breathable membranes — underlay failure at the eaves
ridge tile rebedding — mortar bedding and the dry-fix alternative
dry verge and dry ridge systems — BS 8612 systems
chimney repairs — stacks, pointing, caps and flashings
lead chimney flashings — apron, step and back gutter dimensions
lead soakers and cover flashings — abutment detailing
tile batten spacing by pitch — pitch and lap figures
roof repair pricing guide — pricing the repairs and the re-cover