Summary

The call usually comes in as "the hot water stinks of eggs" or "drains" and the customer is convinced the water is contaminated or the drains are backing up. In a house with a hot water cylinder the explanation is nearly always the same chemistry: sulphate in the mains water, a population of harmless but smelly sulphate-reducing bacteria that have colonised a cylinder which is not getting hot enough to kill them, and a magnesium anode that is giving them the hydrogen they need to turn that sulphate into hydrogen sulphide gas. The gas dissolves in the hot water and is released as the water runs. It is detectable by nose at a few parts per billion, so a very small amount of bacterial activity produces an unmistakeable smell.

The smell is a symptom of a cylinder that is too cool, and a cylinder that is too cool is a Legionella risk as well as a nuisance, so the fix is not just about the odour. Stored hot water should be held at 60 °C and distributed so it reaches 50 °C at the outlets within a minute (55 °C in healthcare), which is the regime set out in the HSE's Approved Code of Practice L8 and its technical guidance HSG274 Part 2. Many cylinders have had the thermostat turned down to 45–50 °C to save money or because the water was "too hot", and that is the temperature band where both the sulphur bacteria and Legionella thrive.

This guide separates the sources of the smell (hot only, hot and cold, one tap only), explains the anode and temperature chemistry, gives a pasteurise-and-flush procedure, and covers the anode replacement options for unvented cylinders. For the Legionella management side see legionella management and legionella risk; for cylinder types and anodes see hot water cylinder types guide; for a cylinder that is too hot rather than too cool see hot water too hot cylinder thermostat.

Key Facts

Quick Reference Table

Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.

Try squote free →
Smell present on Pattern Cause Fix
Hot taps only, whole house Worse after cylinder has stood SRB in cylinder; cool storage; magnesium anode Set 60 °C, pasteurise and flush, change anode
Hot taps only, worse first thing Overnight stagnation As above, cylinder cooling overnight on a timer Run cylinder stat at 60 °C continuously or extend heating period
Hot and cold, whole house Constant Incoming supply (borehole, mains event) Test supply; contact water undertaker or treat private supply
Hot and cold, one outlet Only at that basin/sink Waste trap or anti-vacuum valve Clean/refill trap; replace AAV
Hot only, one outlet That outlet rarely used Dead-leg stagnation Flush, shorten/remove dead-leg
Hot only, after a new cylinder fitted Within weeks of install New magnesium anode in sulphate-rich or softened water Change to aluminium or powered anode; 60 °C
Hot only, after softener fitted Started with softener Softened water accelerating anode hydrogen Anode change; consider hard-water bypass to cylinder feed
Hot only, intermittent, holiday home After unoccupied periods Stagnation Pasteurise on return; run at 60 °C; flush outlets weekly
Smell plus black particles or grey water Hot Sulphide reacting with copper/iron; anode debris Flush, anode check, consider cylinder age
Smell on hot, combi boiler, no cylinder Rare Not the boiler: trap/waste or cold supply Trace as for one outlet / incoming supply

Detailed Guidance

Diagnosis: where is the smell coming from?

ROTTEN-EGG SMELL — DIAGNOSIS
│
├─ Fill a glass from the tap. Take it to another room. Smell it.
│
│   ├─ Glass does NOT smell → the smell is the WASTE, not the water.
│   │      → Trap dry, biofilm in trap/overflow, failed anti-vacuum valve.
│   │
│   └─ Glass smells → the water carries the sulphide.
│        │
│        ├─ Is it on COLD taps too?
│        │     YES → incoming supply. Mains? Report to water undertaker.
│        │           Private borehole? Test for sulphate/H2S; treat.
│        │     NO  → it is the hot water system.
│        │
│        ├─ Is there a CYLINDER?
│        │     NO (combi) → check again; it is almost certainly waste or cold.
│        │     YES → measure stored temperature at the cylinder draw-off.
│        │           Below 55 °C? → that is your cause. Raise to 60 °C.
│        │
│        ├─ Is the cylinder UNVENTED / glass-lined with a MAGNESIUM anode?
│        │     YES → anode is the hydrogen source. Plan an anode change.
│        │     Stainless, no anode → temperature and stagnation alone.
│        │
│        └─ Stagnation? Timer gives short heating periods? Property empty?
│              → pasteurise, flush, and keep the cylinder at 60 °C.
│
└─ Smell with black water or particles → sulphide is attacking copper;
   fix promptly, flush thoroughly, inspect anode and cylinder condition.

Use a probe thermometer, not the dial. Run the hot tap nearest the cylinder and read the temperature after a minute; it should be close to 60 °C. Then read a distant tap after a minute: 50 °C or more is the target. A cylinder "set to 60" that delivers 48 °C has a stat that is miscalibrated, strapped on in the wrong place, or on an immersion that is heating only the top third.

The chemistry

Sulphate-reducing bacteria live in the sediment and biofilm at the bottom of the cylinder, where oxygen is lowest and the water is coolest. They need an electron donor, and hydrogen is the best one available. A magnesium anode corrodes sacrificially to protect the steel tank, and that corrosion reaction releases hydrogen gas continuously; aluminium anodes release far less, and a powered titanium anode none. Give SRB warmth below about 50 °C, sulphate from the mains and hydrogen from the anode, and they turn the sulphate into hydrogen sulphide. Heat the water to 60 °C and they are killed or go dormant; remove the magnesium anode and they lose their fuel. Doing both is the permanent fix. Doing only one, particularly only the anode, sometimes works and sometimes does not.

Stainless steel cylinders rarely suffer, because they have no magnesium anode, but they can still smell if left cool and stagnant for long periods. Vented copper cylinders have no anode at all, and a smell from one is a temperature and stagnation problem, or the immersion heater has a magnesium element sheath on some older types.

Pasteurise and flush

This is the HSG274 Part 2 thermal disinfection approach applied to a domestic cylinder:

  1. Isolate any TMVs' cold supplies or temporarily bypass them if the manufacturer allows, otherwise the outlets will not reach temperature. Warn everyone in the house: the water at the taps will be scalding hot for the duration.
  2. Set the cylinder thermostat to 60–65 °C (do not exceed the cylinder's maximum, and on an unvented cylinder the thermal cut-out is set at around 85–90 °C and must not be interfered with). Heat the whole cylinder; on a two-immersion cylinder run both.
  3. Hold the cylinder at 60 °C or above for at least one hour once it has reached temperature throughout.
  4. Draw off from every hot outlet in turn, starting nearest the cylinder, running each until it reads 60 °C and then for a further five minutes. Include showers (remove the head so the hot flows freely), bath, basins, kitchen, utility, outside tap if on the hot, and any dead-legs.
  5. Reset the thermostat to 60 °C for ongoing operation, reinstate the TMVs, and check the TMV outlet temperatures (41–44 °C depending on fitting).
  6. Advise the customer: do not turn the stat down; if the property will be empty for more than a week, run the cylinder up and flush all outlets on return.

If the smell returns within a few weeks at 60 °C, the anode is the remaining fuel source and should be changed. If the cylinder has heavy sediment (common where the cold feed is from a tank), drain and flush the cylinder from the drain cock before pasteurising.

For a persistent case, or in a let property where a Legionella risk assessment has identified a problem, a chemical disinfection of the whole hot and cold system with chlorine to BS EN 806-4:2010 at 50 mg/l for one hour (or as the method statement specifies), followed by neutralising and flushing, is the next step.

Anode replacement on unvented cylinders

Glass-lined unvented cylinders have a sacrificial anode screwed into the top or side, usually under a plastic cap. The manufacturer's instructions give the inspection interval (typically annually) and the replacement procedure. The work involves isolating the cylinder, releasing pressure through the temperature and pressure relief valve or a drain, lowering the level below the anode port, unscrewing the old anode (often badly wasted, sometimes little more than a core wire) and fitting the new one with PTFE or the specified sealant, then refilling, venting and testing the safety controls.

Options:

Because the cylinder is unvented, the person doing the work must hold the G3 qualification (Approved Document G, Section G3, Building Regulations 2010) and should check and test the expansion vessel or air gap, the temperature and pressure relief valve, the expansion relief valve and the tundish discharge while the cylinder is open. Record the work on the cylinder's benchmark or service log; it is a condition of most warranties.

Combination boilers, thermal stores and heat pump cylinders

A combi boiler heats mains water on demand and stores none, so it cannot grow SRB; a rotten-egg smell in a combi house is from the cold supply or a waste trap. Thermal stores and heat batteries store heating water, not potable water, and the domestic hot water passes through a coil or plate exchanger; the smell cannot come from the store but can come from a rarely used secondary circuit.

Heat pump cylinders are the growing problem area. Heat pumps run most efficiently at low flow temperatures, and many are set to store hot water at 45–50 °C with a weekly or fortnightly "Legionella cycle" where an immersion boosts the cylinder to 60 °C for an hour. If that cycle is disabled, fails (immersion tripped, programmer reset) or is too infrequent, the cylinder lives in exactly the SRB temperature band, and because heat pump cylinders are very often glass-lined with magnesium anodes, the smell follows. Check the cycle is enabled and verify it with a temperature log; see heat pump cylinders.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the smelly water dangerous to drink or bathe in?

Hydrogen sulphide at the concentrations found in a domestic cylinder is unpleasant but not a health hazard in itself, and the sulphate-reducing bacteria that make it are not pathogens. The concern is what the smell indicates: a cylinder running below 60 °C is also a cylinder that can support Legionella, which is dangerous when inhaled in shower spray. Hot water from a stored cylinder should not be drunk in any case. Treat the smell as a warning that the hot water system needs bringing up to the L8 regime, not as a contamination emergency.

Why did the smell start after a new cylinder was fitted?

A new glass-lined cylinder comes with a fresh, highly active magnesium anode producing plenty of hydrogen, and if the installer set the thermostat conservatively at 50 °C or left the timer on short periods, the SRB already present in small numbers in the water have everything they need. Set the stat to 60 °C and pasteurise; if the smell persists, swap the anode for aluminium or powered. In softened or high-sulphate water areas it is worth specifying a stainless cylinder or a powered anode from the outset.

Can I just turn the cylinder up and leave the anode alone?

Often yes. Holding the cylinder at 60 °C kills the bacteria and most cases do not return. Where they do, it is because the cylinder cools between heating periods (a timer giving two short boosts a day), because sediment at the base stays cooler than the bulk water, or because a magnesium anode in softened water is producing enough hydrogen to feed a population even at the margins. In those installations an anode change is the next step. Never simply remove the anode and leave the port blanked on a glass-lined cylinder; the steel will corrode and the warranty is void.

Does a water softener cause the smell?

It can contribute. Softened water has higher sodium and chloride, which increases the corrosion rate of a magnesium anode and therefore the hydrogen it produces, and softened water is often found in houses where the hot water is run cooler to limit scale. The fix is the same: 60 °C storage and an aluminium or powered anode. Some installers feed the cylinder from the hard-water bypass for this reason, at the cost of scale in the cylinder.

What temperature should a hot water cylinder be set to?

60 °C stored, with hot water reaching outlets at 50 °C within a minute, per HSE Approved Code of Practice L8 and HSG274 Part 2. Where there is a scald risk (children, elderly or disabled users, care settings), fit thermostatic mixing valves at the relevant outlets to deliver 41–44 °C rather than turning the cylinder down. Approved Document G3 requires a bath hot-water outlet in a new dwelling to be limited to 48 °C, which is achieved with a TMV, not by cooler storage.

Regulations & Standards