Summary
"The key won't turn" is the lock call-out that is most often misdiagnosed, because three different components can produce the same symptom and the customer has usually already forced it. A euro cylinder on a uPVC or composite door sits in front of a multipoint gearbox and behind a handle; a mortice sashlock on a timber door has the cylinder (the levers) and the bolt in one case, but the bolt still has to clear a keep in a frame that moves with the seasons. A key that will not turn can mean a cylinder problem, a gearbox or lock-case problem, or simply a door that has dropped 3 mm so the hooks and deadbolt are pressing on the keeps and loading the mechanism so the key cannot move it. Fitting a new cylinder to a door that needs its hinges adjusting fixes nothing and costs the customer £80.
The order of diagnosis is always the same and it is the first thing in the decision tree below: open the door and try again. Everything else follows from that. The second rule is not to force it. A key is a thin piece of brass or nickel silver; the cylinder cam, the gearbox follower and the lock bolt are steel. Forcing the key snaps the key, and a snapped key in a cylinder turns a £20 adjustment into a cylinder replacement. Mole grips on a key are the mark of a locksmith who will be replacing the cylinder whether it needed it or not.
This guide covers euro cylinders in uPVC, composite and aluminium doors, mortice locks and rim cylinders (nightlatches) on timber doors, and the related alignment faults. It gives the diagnostic sequence, the fixes, the standards that replacement hardware must meet for insurance, and the sizing information needed to carry the right cylinder in the van. For the uPVC alignment and gearbox fault where the handle, not the key, is the problem see upvc door wont lock; for lock standards and insurance see security locks; for gearbox replacement see upvc door lock mechanism replacement.
Key Facts
- Door open test — the single most important diagnostic: key turns with the door open but not closed means alignment, not the lock.
- Euro cylinder sizes — measured from the centre of the cam fixing screw hole to each end, in millimetres, external/internal (e.g. 35/45); common sizes 30/30 to 50/50; the cylinder should sit flush with or no more than 3 mm proud of the handle or escutcheon to resist snapping.
- Cylinder types — euro double (key both sides), euro thumbturn (key outside, turn inside), euro single (key one side, blank the other), oval (older uPVC and aluminium), rim cylinder (nightlatch), and scandinavian/round profiles on some aluminium doors.
- Cylinder standards — BS EN 1303:2015 (performance grading), TS 007:2014 Kitemark 1-star, 3-star cylinders; Sold Secure Diamond (SS312); PAS 24:2022 for the complete doorset. Secured by Design requires 3-star cylinder or 1-star cylinder with 2-star security handle.
- Mortice lock standards — BS 3621:2017 (thief-resistant lock assembly, key egress both sides), BS 8621:2017 (keyless egress inside, for escape routes), BS 10621:2017 (dual mode); most insurers require BS 3621 or equivalent on final exit doors of timber.
- Multipoint gearbox — the centre case behind the handles; the key drives the deadbolt and, on many types, also lifts or releases the hooks; a failed gearbox typically presents as the key turning freely with no bolt movement, or the handle and key both locking solid.
- Cam — the lug on the cylinder that engages the gearbox follower; a cylinder with a worn or broken cam turns the key but moves nothing.
- Anti-snap — 3-star cylinders have a sacrificial section and hardened anti-drill pins; replacing a snapped or worn cylinder is the moment to upgrade.
- Keyed alike and master keys — new cylinders can be keyed alike to existing ones from the same manufacturer and suite; otherwise expect new keys for every door replaced.
- Lubricant — graphite powder or a PTFE-based dry lubricant into the keyway; never oil or grease (WD-40 is a cleaner, not a lubricant; it dries to a gum that attracts dirt).
- Common key faults — a copy cut from a copy (tolerance stack-up), a worn key with rounded bitting, a bent key, a key for a different cylinder on the same ring, a key with a snapped tip left in the plug.
- Door drop — a uPVC door drops on its hinges over time; 2–4 mm of drop is enough to load the hooks against the keeps; adjust the hinges (flag hinges have height, compression and lateral adjustment via Allen screws under caps) before touching the lock.
- Thermal movement — composite and uPVC doors expand in heat and swell in damp; a door that locks in winter and not in summer, or vice versa, is an alignment and compression issue.
- Timber door swelling — a timber door that will not lock in wet weather has swollen in the frame; the deadbolt is binding in the keep; plane and seal, or adjust the keep, not the lock.
- Snapped key removal — a broken-key extractor (£8–£20 kit) or a jigsaw blade with teeth facing out; do not push it further in; if it is deep, remove the cylinder and push it out from the cam end.
- Costs — locksmith call-out £65–£120 regionally, £90–£180 London; replacement 3-star cylinder £35–£80 supplied and fitted plus call-out; mortice lock BS 3621 £40–£90 plus 1–1.5 hours; multipoint gearbox £60–£150 plus 1–2 hours; hinge and keep adjustment 20–40 minutes within the call-out.
Quick Reference Table
Diagnosed the problem? Create a repair quote in minutes with squote.
Try squote free →| Symptom | Door open test result | Most likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key goes in fully, won't turn, door closed | Turns fine open | Door dropped or swollen; bolts loading keeps | Adjust hinges/keeps; plane timber door |
| Key goes in fully, won't turn, door open or closed | Won't turn open | Cylinder pin stuck, dirt, worn key, wrong key | Lubricate; try spare key; replace cylinder |
| Key goes in only partway | — | Foreign object, snapped key tip, damaged pin | Extract object; replace cylinder if pin damaged |
| Key turns but nothing happens | Same open | Cam sheared or gearbox follower broken | Replace cylinder (cam) or gearbox |
| Key turns 90° then stops, bolt partly out | Same open | Deadbolt or hook jammed; gearbox fault | Check keep clearance; replace gearbox |
| Key turns only from one side | Same open | Cam clutch failed on one half (double cylinder) | Replace cylinder |
| Key stiff but turns; getting worse | Same open | Worn pins, dirt, lack of lubrication | Clean and dry-lubricate; replace if no better |
| Thumbturn turns but key won't | — | Key worn or wrong; or cylinder clutch | Try spare key; replace cylinder |
| Key turns, handle then won't lift (uPVC) | Handle fine open | Alignment: hooks missing keeps | Hinge and keep adjustment |
| Key turns, handle won't lift (door open) | Same open | Gearbox failed | Replace gearbox |
| Mortice lock key won't turn, door open | Same open | Lever stuck, broken spring, dirt, wrong key | Lubricate; strip and clean; replace lock |
| Nightlatch key won't turn | Same open | Rim cylinder worn or cam loose; tailbar misaligned | Tighten cylinder screws; replace rim cylinder |
| Key works intermittently | Varies | Worn key or cylinder; deadbolt catching in cold/heat | Spare key test; keep adjustment; replace |
Detailed Guidance
Diagnosis: the decision tree
KEY WON'T TURN — DIAGNOSIS
│
├─ 1. Open the door (from inside, or via another door/window if locked out).
│ Try the key with the door OPEN.
│
│ ├─ Key turns normally with door open?
│ │ └─ ALIGNMENT FAULT. Bolts/hooks are loaded against keeps.
│ │ ├─ uPVC/composite: adjust flag hinges (height, lateral, compression),
│ │ │ check keeps; see upvc-door-wont-lock.
│ │ └─ Timber: deadbolt binding in keep. Check for swelling, dropped
│ │ hinges, keep position. Adjust keep or ease door; do not file the bolt.
│ │
│ └─ Key still won't turn with door open?
│ └─ LOCK OR CYLINDER FAULT. Continue.
│
├─ 2. Does the key go in fully?
│ ├─ NO ──> Obstruction. Look in the keyway with a torch. Snapped key tip?
│ │ Extract with hook/extractor. Damaged pin? Replace cylinder.
│ └─ YES ──> Continue.
│
├─ 3. Try a different key (spare, original not a copy).
│ ├─ Spare works ──> Key fault. Cut a new key from the ORIGINAL or by code.
│ └─ Spare also fails ──> Cylinder or mechanism. Continue.
│
├─ 4. Dry-lubricate (graphite/PTFE), insert and withdraw key several times, try.
│ ├─ Now turns ──> Dirt/wear. Advise replacement if stiffness returns.
│ └─ Still won't turn ──> Continue.
│
├─ 5. Does the key turn but do NOTHING (bolt doesn't move)?
│ ├─ YES, euro cylinder ──> Cam sheared or gearbox follower broken.
│ │ Remove cylinder: cam intact? → gearbox. Cam broken/loose? → cylinder.
│ └─ YES, mortice/rim ──> Lock case/cylinder internals. Replace lock or rim cylinder.
│
├─ 6. Key turns partway then stops hard?
│ ├─ Euro ──> Deadbolt or hooks jammed in the case. Remove cylinder, operate
│ │ gearbox with a follower/screwdriver via the cam slot. Moves? Cylinder
│ │ fault. Jammed? Gearbox fault.
│ └─ Mortice ──> Bolt jammed in case or against keep edge. Remove lock, test out of door.
│
└─ 7. Thumbturn works, key side doesn't (euro)?
└─ Key side half of cylinder failed or key worn. Replace cylinder (upgrade to 3-star).
Alignment faults on uPVC and composite doors
Most calls. A uPVC door hangs on two or three flag hinges, each with cap-covered Allen adjusters for height (lifting the door), lateral position (moving it toward or away from the hinge jamb) and compression (pulling the door onto the seals). Over years the door drops a few millimetres and the hooks, rollers and deadbolt of the multipoint arrive low against their keeps. With the door closed, the mechanism is pre-loaded, so the key (which drives the deadbolt and often the hooks) cannot move it. Open the door and everything works.
Diagnose by marking the keeps: close the door, lift the handle, open it, and look for witness marks where the hooks have been striking the keep edges. Lift the door at the hinges in 1 mm increments (the hinge adjustment screws typically give 3–5 mm range) and test. Some systems have adjustable keeps as well (a cam or an eccentric roller); move them rather than the hinges where only one point is catching. Then check compression: a door compressed too hard against a swollen weatherseal also loads the mechanism. Full method is in upvc door wont lock. Twenty to forty minutes, no parts, and the customer's lock is fine.
Seasonal variation (locks in winter, not in summer, or the reverse) is the same fault with thermal movement added; adjust for the mid-point and reduce compression slightly.
Cylinder faults
A euro cylinder is a plug of five or six pin stacks (or a dimple, disc or sidebar system on high-security types) with a cam at the centre that drives the gearbox follower. It fails in predictable ways:
- Dirt and wear: pins stick, the key becomes stiff, then will not turn. Dry graphite or PTFE lubricant and working the key often frees it; this is a warning that the cylinder is near the end of its life.
- Worn or poorly cut key: a copy of a copy has stacked tolerance and lifts pins to the wrong height. If the original key works and the copy does not, cut the next copy from the original or to the manufacturer's code card.
- Snapped key: the tip stays in the plug. Hook it out with an extractor or a fine jigsaw blade (teeth outward), pulling, not pushing. If it will not come, remove the cylinder (undo the fixing screw at the edge of the door, turn the cam with the remaining key stub or a screwdriver to the 12 o'clock position, slide it out) and push the tip through from the cam end. A snapped key usually means the cylinder was already stiff; recommend replacement.
- Cam failure: the key turns freely through 360° and nothing happens. Remove the cylinder and look: a loose or broken cam is a cylinder replacement. An intact cam means the gearbox follower has failed.
- Clutch failure on a double cylinder: anti-lockout "clutched" cylinders let a key work from one side while a key is in the other; the clutch wears and one side stops driving the cam. Replace.
- Attack damage: a cylinder that has been snapped, drilled or bumped is a replacement regardless of whether it still turns, and a police report may be needed for insurance.
Measure before you buy: with the cylinder out, measure from the centre of the fixing screw hole to each end. Fit a cylinder that finishes flush with or within 3 mm of the handle or escutcheon; a cylinder protruding more than 3 mm is a snapping target. Upgrade to a TS 007 3-star or a Sold Secure Diamond cylinder; the £20–£40 premium over a basic cylinder is what the customer's insurer and the police would expect.
Gearbox and lock-case faults
If the cylinder is good (key turns the cam freely with the cylinder out of the door, or a known-good cylinder behaves the same way in the door), the fault is in the multipoint gearbox. Symptoms: the key turns the cam but the deadbolt does not move or moves and jams; the handle will not lift with the door open; the key turns 90° and stops dead. With the cylinder removed, operate the follower with a flat screwdriver through the cam slot: a gearbox that will not throw the bolt from the follower is broken internally (a snapped spring, a stripped gear or a sheared bolt tail). Replace the gearbox or the complete strip; identify the make by the markings on the faceplate, the backset (centre of the cylinder to the faceplate edge, usually 35 mm or 45 mm), the PZ dimension (handle centre to cylinder centre, commonly 92 mm) and the faceplate width. Full method in upvc door lock mechanism replacement.
A mortice sashlock or deadlock on a timber door fails similarly: a broken lever spring leaves a lever in the wrong position so the key will not pass; a worn bolt stump jams; a lock that has had the wrong key forced has a bent lever. Remove the lock (forend screws, then draw it out of the mortice) and test on the bench. A BS 3621 lock is not worth repairing; replace like-for-like on case size (typically 64 mm or 76 mm case, 44 mm or 57 mm backset) and keep spacing.
Rim cylinders and nightlatches
A rim cylinder (the round brass cylinder of a nightlatch) is held by two screws through the backplate and drives the latch via a flat tailbar. If the key turns stiffly or not at all, check first that the cylinder has not rotated in the door (loose backplate screws let the whole cylinder turn with the key, so the tailbar does not move the latch). Tighten the screws; if the tailbar is bent or too long, trim it to the manufacturer's length marks. A worn rim cylinder is a direct replacement; match the make if the nightlatch body is to stay, or replace the whole nightlatch with a BS 3621 model if it is the sole lock on a final exit door.
Timber door alignment
A timber door that will not lock in wet weather has swollen and the deadbolt is riding on the edge of the keep, loading the lock. Open the door: the key turns. Look at the keep for witness marks. Options: adjust the keep (move it 1–2 mm by plugging and re-drilling, or file the keep aperture, never the bolt), or ease and seal the door edge (a swollen door is an unsealed door; plane 1–2 mm from the leading edge and prime and paint all edges including the top and bottom). Dropped hinges with worn pins or loose screws are the other common cause; replace screws with longer ones into sound timber, or replace the hinges.
Preventing the callback
After any lock repair: dry-lubricate the cylinder (never oil), check and adjust the keeps and hinges so nothing is loaded with the door closed, check the cylinder protrusion, and cut any new keys from the original. Tell the customer to lubricate the cylinder once a year with graphite or PTFE, not oil or WD-40, and to stop using a key that has become stiff rather than forcing it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does the key work with the door open but not closed?
Because the lock is not the problem. With the door closed, the hooks, rollers or deadbolt are pressing against the keeps because the door has dropped, swelled or is being compressed too hard against the seals. That load prevents the key from moving the mechanism. Adjust the hinges and keeps on a uPVC or composite door, or ease and reseal a swollen timber door. Replacing the cylinder changes nothing.
Can I use WD-40 in a lock?
No. WD-40 is a water-displacing solvent that cleans and then dries to a thin gum; in a cylinder it attracts dust and eventually makes the pins stick worse. Use a dry graphite powder or a PTFE-based lock lubricant, a small puff into the keyway, then work the key in and out. Oil and grease are worse than WD-40 for the same reason.
What cylinder should I fit as a replacement?
For a uPVC or composite door, a TS 007:2014 Kitemark 3-star cylinder (or a 1-star cylinder with a 2-star security handle), or a Sold Secure Diamond cylinder, sized so it sits flush or within 3 mm of the handle. These resist snapping, drilling and bumping, satisfy Secured by Design and are what insurers expect on an external door. For a timber final exit door, the lock itself should be BS 3621:2017 (or BS 8621 where keyless internal egress is needed), and the insurer will usually ask for it by name.
The key snapped in the lock. Can I get it out without replacing the cylinder?
Often. Pull the broken piece out with a broken-key extractor or a fine jigsaw blade with the teeth facing outward, hooking the bitting. Do not push it further in and do not use superglue on the key stub. If it is deep, remove the cylinder and push it out from the cam end. Then ask why it snapped: a key that needed forcing was already telling you the cylinder was worn or the door was misaligned. Check the alignment and consider a new cylinder.
How much does a locksmith charge to fix a key that won't turn?
Expect a call-out of £65–£120 regionally (£90–£180 London) that covers diagnosis and simple adjustment. Hinge and keep adjustment is usually within the call-out. A replacement 3-star cylinder adds £35–£80 supplied and fitted; a BS 3621 mortice lock £40–£90 plus 1–1.5 hours; a multipoint gearbox £60–£150 plus 1–2 hours. Out-of-hours and lockout calls carry a premium of 50–100%.
Regulations & Standards
BS EN 1303:2015 — Building hardware: cylinders for locks. Requirements and test methods (grading for durability, key security and attack resistance).
TS 007:2014 — Enhanced security performance requirements for replacement cylinders and/or associated security hardware (the 1-star, 2-star and 3-star Kitemark scheme).
BS 3621:2017 — Thief-resistant lock assembly: key egress; BS 8621:2017 — keyless egress; BS 10621:2017 — dual mode.
BS EN 12209:2016 — Building hardware: mechanically operated locks and locking plates.
PAS 24:2022 — Enhanced security performance requirements for doorsets and windows in the UK.
Sold Secure SS312 Diamond — Master Locksmiths Association cylinder attack-resistance standard.
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document Q: Security – Dwellings (2015 edition) — new dwellings: doorsets to PAS 24 or equivalent.
Building Regulations 2010, Approved Document B Volume 1 — final exit doors on escape routes to be openable without a key from inside (relevant to BS 8621 selection).
Secured by Design Homes guidance — police-preferred specification for cylinders and doorsets.
Master Locksmiths Association – Choosing a lock and TS 007 explained — consumer and trade guidance on cylinder standards
Secured by Design – Homes guide — police-preferred specifications for doors and cylinders
Door & Hardware Federation – TS 007 cylinder security — the TS 007 scheme and star ratings
BSI Kitemark – Enhanced security cylinders TS 007 — Kitemark scheme information
Approved Document Q: Security – Dwellings — security requirements for new dwellings
Sold Secure – Test standards and approved products — SS312 Diamond cylinder standard
upvc door wont lock — the handle-side version of the alignment fault, with the full hinge adjustment method
upvc door lock mechanism replacement — replacing the multipoint gearbox when the cylinder is not the fault
security locks — BS 3621, PAS 24 and insurer requirements
door not closing properly — the alignment faults that precede a lock that will not turn
composite vs upvc door — how door construction affects thermal movement and locking
door hanging — rehanging a timber door that has dropped